Learning path · Level 1 · Tutorial 3

Deciding When AI Should Assist

Decide whether AI should assist with a task, whether a person must retain the decision, or whether AI use is inappropriate for the situation.

  • Level: Beginner
  • Duration: 11 min
  • 7 steps
Start tutorial Back to the path
Deciding When AI Should Assist

What you will go through

  1. Separate Support from the Final Decision Separate useful AI preparation from a decision a person must retain. 1 min
  2. Consider What Happens If AI Is Wrong Compare AI-related errors by their consequences and by how easily they can be corrected before people rely on them. 2 min
  3. Do Not Confuse Plausibility with Dependability Learn to recognize when polished AI wording hides uncertainty that matters for the proposed use. 2 min
  4. Ask Whether You Can Check the Result Decide whether an AI output can be meaningfully assessed before people rely on it. 2 min
  5. Recognize When Human Expertise Is Essential Distinguish personal judgment from qualified professional expertise, while keeping useful AI preparation within clear boundaries. 2 min
  6. Choose an Appropriate Role for AI Choose an appropriate role for an AI assistant by applying the tutorial's five assessment headings to the exact proposed use. 2 min
  7. Make and Explain Your Decision Choose an appropriate AI role for everyday tasks and explain the boundary between support and decision-making. 2 min

What you will learn

  • Assess a proposed AI use by considering the consequences of error, uncertainty, and whether the result can be checked.
  • Separate a useful support task from a final decision that requires human judgment.
  • Choose between AI assistance, human-led work, and avoiding AI for a set of everyday scenarios, giving a reason for each choice.
  • Recognize situations where a qualified professional is needed rather than relying on an AI answer.

Before you start

  • Identifying AI Tasks and the Products Around Models

Step 1 of 7

Separate Support from the Final Decision

Separate useful AI preparation from a decision a person must retain.

Assign a role, not just a tool

One task can contain two roles

An AI assistant may be able to produce an answer, but that alone does not decide its role. Ask: what is the assistant doing, and who determines the outcome?

A Support task helps a person prepare: drafting, suggesting, sorting, or organizing. The person considers the result.

A Final decision determines what will happen, what will be promised, or which option will be chosen. A person must retain that decision.

Drafting is different from deciding

A two-part workflow shows an AI assistant creating event-announcement drafts and an organizer reviewing them before making a choice.

The AI assistant can prepare announcement drafts. Alex, the organizer, retains the decision about what Riverside Community Day will promise attendees.

Split Alex's event task

Assistance is not delegation

Delegation means allowing AI to determine the outcome without meaningful human judgment. It is not meaningful review if a person simply accepts whatever the AI assistant says.

Instead, separate a larger request into two parts:

  • Support task: a bounded contribution the AI assistant can prepare for review.
  • Final decision: the choice a person makes after considering the situation.

This separation lets a person use useful output without handing over responsibility.

Example

Worked example

Alex needs an announcement for Riverside Community Day.

Support task: Ask an AI assistant to draft a short announcement using these confirmed facts: Saturday, 10:00–12:00, Community Hall, and free entry.

Final decision: Alex decides whether the announcement should promise anything else to attendees, such as a particular activity or service. The AI assistant may suggest wording, but it must not make that promise for Alex.

Tip

Keep the boundary visible

A draft is material to consider. A promise is a commitment that someone must choose and stand behind.

Identify the role of each action

Practice: support or final decision?

Match each action to its role in Alex's event work.

Tap an item and then its matching pair.

Step 2 of 7

Consider What Happens If AI Is Wrong

Compare AI-related errors by their consequences and by how easily they can be corrected before people rely on them.

Look beyond the quality of the output

Two questions before relying on AI

An AI assistant can produce an answer quickly, but the important question is: what happens if that answer is wrong?

Consequences are the effects of an error and the people affected by it. An awkward event announcement may be inconvenient. A wrong instruction that attendees follow can disrupt their plans.

Reversibility asks whether the error can be fixed before it causes lasting effects. A draft can usually be changed before anyone sees it. Once people have acted on incorrect information, a correction may arrive too late for some of them.

Before and after people act

Two timelines compare an editable event draft before sharing with an incorrect message that people have already acted on before a correction is sent.

The same type of error can have very different consequences depending on whether people have already acted on it.

Compare the path of an error

A practical comparison

Compare the stage of the error, not just how polished the AI output sounds. Speed and convenience do not make an error less important.

Example

Riverside Community Day

Alex is organizing Riverside Community Day: Saturday, 10:00–12:00, at Community Hall, with free entry.

Why the difference matters

The first case remains under Alex’s control because it is still a draft. In the second case, correcting the message cannot fully undo a visitor’s wasted journey or missed time. As consequences become more serious or less reversible, a person needs stronger control over what is released or decided.

Consequences and reversibility

Compare the effect of each error.

A correction is most useful before people rely on the output.
Proposed AI outputConsequences if wrongReversibility
Unshared event draft has awkward wordingAlex can revise it; no attendee has acted on itEasy to correct before sharing
Sent attendee message gives the wrong start timeVisitors may arrive at the wrong time or miss part of the eventHarder to undo after visitors act

Apply the comparison

Choose the higher-impact error

Two AI assistant errors occur for Riverside Community Day. Which one needs stronger human control, based on its consequences and reversibility?

Step 3 of 7

Do Not Confuse Plausibility with Dependability

Learn to recognize when polished AI wording hides uncertainty that matters for the proposed use.

Look past the confident wording

A polished answer can still be uncertain

Plausible is not the same as dependable

An AI assistant can produce an answer that sounds clear, confident, and reasonable. That makes it plausible—but not automatically correct or suitable for the situation.

A dependable answer needs the right facts and context for the use you plan. Polished wording cannot supply facts that were missing from the request or resolve an ambiguous instruction.

Same polish, different uncertainty

A comparison between disposable creative event ideas and a polished factual event notice supported by incomplete information.

Creative options can be discarded. A polished factual claim may still be uncertain when important information is missing.

Match uncertainty to the proposed use

Missing information still matters

Where uncertainty comes from

Uncertainty increases when a request leaves out relevant facts, provides incomplete context, or can reasonably mean more than one thing. The answer may still sound certain because fluent wording is not evidence that those gaps disappeared.

The important question is not “Does this sound convincing?” It is “What is still unknown, and will anyone rely on this claim?”

Example

Example: ideas versus a claim

Alex asks an AI assistant for three playful headline ideas for Riverside Community Day: Saturday, 10:00–12:00, Community Hall, free entry. The ideas are disposable creative options: Alex can select one, revise it, or discard all of them.

Now imagine the AI assistant adds: “Free parking is available all day.” Alex did not provide that fact. The sentence may sound helpful and polished, but people could plan around it. Here, unresolved uncertainty matters much more.

Practice: polish is not proof

Test the distinction

A confident, polished AI answer is dependable even when the request leaves key facts unstated.

Choose the sound judgment

Apply the idea

Which statement best distinguishes acceptable uncertainty from concerning uncertainty?

Step 4 of 7

Ask Whether You Can Check the Result

Decide whether an AI output can be meaningfully assessed before people rely on it.

What makes an output checkable?

Checkability

Checkability

Checkability means having a realistic way to judge the relevant quality or correctness of an AI output before anyone relies on it.

Ask three practical questions:

  • Do I have suitable information to compare against the output?
  • Do I understand enough to recognize an important error?
  • Do I have enough time to check it before it is used?

Rereading a polished answer may improve its wording, but it does not show that a factual or technical claim is correct.

A realistic checking route

A flow diagram showing an AI output passing through source information, understanding, and time checks before it is used or paused for revision.

Before use, an output needs a checking route: relevant information, enough understanding, and enough time.

Different outputs need different checks

Comparing checking routes

Checkability depends on the exact output and the person who must assess it. It is not the same as proving that there is one perfect answer.

A checking route must fit the proposed output.
Proposed outputWhat the checker needsCan Alex check it before use?
An event blurbThe supplied schedule: Saturday, 10:00–12:00, Community Hall, free entryYes. Alex can compare each fact before sharing.
A technical safety claimRelevant technical expertiseNot realistically. Alex cannot judge the claim from wording alone.
Creative title ideasThe event purpose and audienceYes. Alex can judge fit and discard unsuitable ideas.

Use the route before relying on the result

Example

Example: a checkable event draft

Alex asks an AI assistant to draft an announcement for Riverside Community Day using the supplied facts: Saturday, 10:00–12:00, Community Hall, and free entry.

The Support task is drafting clear wording. Alex can check the result against the short schedule before posting it. That is a realistic checking route.

If the same AI assistant makes a technical safety claim about equipment at Community Hall, confident wording is not enough. Alex lacks the relevant understanding to assess that claim, so simply rereading it cannot establish correctness.

Practice: identify the checking route

Assess checkability

Match each proposed AI output to the realistic checking condition for Alex.

Tap an item and then its matching pair.

Step 5 of 7

Recognize When Human Expertise Is Essential

Distinguish personal judgment from qualified professional expertise, while keeping useful AI preparation within clear boundaries.

Decide who has the needed judgment

Personal judgment and expertise

Who should decide?

Some Final decisions depend on values, relationships, local context, or trade-offs. An AI assistant may organize options as a Support task, but a person should make the Final decision when those human considerations matter.

Other decisions need more than personal judgment: they need a qualified professional. For a personalized medical or legal decision, a polished AI answer—or approval by someone who cannot recognize the relevant errors—is not a dependable basis for action.

Use AI assistance for bounded preparation. Use Human-led work when a person must weigh the context. Choose Avoid AI for this use when the proposed AI role tries to determine a decision that requires a qualified professional.

A role boundary

Diagram showing an AI assistant preparing materials, a person making a context-based choice, and a clinician handling a specialized decision.

The same broad topic can contain different roles: AI preparation, personal judgment, and qualified professional expertise.

Keep the boundary meaningful

Example

Example: preparation is not the decision

Jordan notices symptoms and considers asking an AI assistant which medication change to make.

Choice: Avoid AI for this use

Reason: Choosing a personalized medication change can depend on health details and clinical judgment. A generic review cannot reliably check whether the choice is suitable.

Boundary: An AI assistant may help draft general questions for a clinician as a Support task. A clinician—not the AI assistant or an unqualified reviewer—makes the Final decision.

Warning

Approval is not automatically a safeguard

A human approval step is meaningful only when the reviewer has the information, understanding, and authority needed to recognize the relevant errors. A generic sign-off does not turn an expert decision into a dependable AI-assisted one.

Practice: match the role to the use

Choose the role boundary

Match each proposed role to the appropriate choice label.

Tap an item and then its matching pair.

Step 6 of 7

Choose an Appropriate Role for AI

Choose an appropriate role for an AI assistant by applying the tutorial's five assessment headings to the exact proposed use.

Use the five-question map

Start with the proposed role

Choose a role for the exact proposed use—not for an entire topic or product. Use five headings to guide your judgment:

  • Consequences: What happens if this is wrong, and who is affected?
  • Reversibility: Can the error be corrected before lasting effects?
  • Uncertainty: What important facts are missing or unclear?
  • Checkability: Can the result be realistically assessed before anyone relies on it?
  • Who should decide?: Does the outcome require personal judgment or a qualified professional?

This is a judgment map, not a numerical score. A task can be suitable for a limited Support task while its Final decision remains with a person.

A compact judgment map

One proposed task is examined through five connected questions before leading to checked support, a human decision, or rejection of an automated decision role.

Consider all five headings before choosing the role for a specific proposed use.

Match the role to its boundary

Three possible choices

The boundary is as important as the choice. It states what an AI assistant may prepare and what it must not determine.

Choice and boundary guide

Apply the label to the role that is actually proposed. Changing the role can change the choice, even within the same subject area.

Choose for the specified use, not for an entire domain.
ChoiceWhen it fitsBoundary
AI assistanceA bounded output can be checked or discarded before use.The AI assistant supports a Support task; a person retains the Final decision.
Human-led workThe proposed workflow leaves the Final decision with a capable person or qualified professional.The AI assistant may prepare checkable material but does not determine the outcome.
Avoid AI for this useThe proposed AI role delegates a decision that AI cannot determine dependably in the available conditions.Reject that AI role. Use a human or non-AI alternative for the decision.

Example

Worked event-planning use

Alex gives an AI assistant only these confirmed facts: Riverside Community Day is Saturday, 10:00–12:00, at Community Hall, with free entry. Alex asks for two short announcement drafts.

Choice: AI assistance

Reason: The drafts are disposable and can be checked against the supplied facts before anything is shared.

Boundary: The AI assistant may draft wording. Alex makes the Final decision about what to publish and must not let the draft invent promises for attendees.

Make a choice and set the boundary

Apply the map to a proposed delegation

Alex receives three requests for services at Riverside Community Day on Saturday, 10:00–12:00 at Community Hall, with free entry. Alex asks an AI assistant to choose which services the event will promise attendees. Information about venue limits, costs, and available volunteers is incomplete.

Write three labeled lines:

  • Choice: use the applicable tutorial choice label.
  • Reason: name the decisive concern.
  • Boundary: state one limited Support task the AI assistant may do and who makes the Final decision.

Write at least 120 characters (0/120).

Step 7 of 7

Make and Explain Your Decision

Choose an appropriate AI role for everyday tasks and explain the boundary between support and decision-making.

Use the decision map

Use the complete decision map

Use the same decision map for the exact proposed use:

Consequences: What happens if this is wrong, and who is affected?

Reversibility: Can an error be corrected before lasting effects?

Uncertainty: What important facts are missing or unclear?

Checkability: Can the result be realistically assessed before anyone relies on it?

Who should decide?: Does the outcome require personal judgment or a qualified professional?

Then explain the result briefly:

Choice: use exactly one choice label.
Reason: name the decisive concern.
Boundary: state what an AI assistant may do as a Support task and what it must not decide as the Final decision.

There is no blanket rule about AI. Decide for the specific role proposed.

Assess before choosing

A task card passes through five symbolic checks before reaching three possible decision cards.

Assess the proposed role through all five headings before stating a choice and boundary.

Apply the labels

Classify the complete workflow

Match each complete proposed workflow to its best choice label. Classify the workflow as described—not a different request you could make to an AI assistant.

Tap an item and then its matching pair.

Final application

Make and explain three decisions

Classify each complete proposed workflow below. For each scenario, write three labeled lines using exactly one choice label: AI assistance, Human-led work, or Avoid AI for this use.

A. A book-swap organizer gives confirmed event details to an AI assistant and requests three cheerful poster taglines. The organizer will review every tagline and may edit or discard it before use.

B. A neighbourhood group is considering a new time for its weekly meeting. Members have different transport needs, caring commitments, and preferences. The proposed workflow asks an AI assistant to group written comments into themes; group members will review those themes and make the Final decision about the meeting time.

C. A person asks an AI assistant to decide whether they should reduce the dose of prescribed medication at a routine medication review because of an ongoing side effect. The AI assistant has no complete medical record or clinical examination.

For every response, state a decisive reason and a clear boundary. For C, name the qualified professional who should make the Final decision. Different wording is fine when the choice and boundary fit the facts.

Write at least 300 characters (0/300).

Finish

Summary

Decision map recap

You can make a reasoned choice about an AI assistant without treating it as always useful or always inappropriate.

  • Assess the exact proposed use with Consequences, Reversibility, Uncertainty, Checkability, and Who should decide?.
  • Use AI assistance for bounded Support tasks whose results can be checked, revised, or discarded before use.
  • Use Human-led work when a capable person retains the Final decision and may use limited, checkable AI preparation.
  • Choose Avoid AI for this use when the proposed role delegates an outcome that cannot be determined dependably in the available conditions.
  • For a personalized decision requiring expertise, a qualified professional makes the Final decision; an AI assistant may only help with an appropriate Support task.
  • Explain your result with Choice:, Reason:, and Boundary:.
  • Next, you will apply basic safety checks to the information and claims involved in AI-assisted work.

Tutorial complete

Congratulations! You completed: Deciding When AI Should Assist

You can now choose an appropriate role for an AI assistant, preserve meaningful human judgment, and recognize when a qualified professional must decide.

Download the App now to have access to + 5000 free courses, exercises, certificates and lots of content without paying anything!

  • 100% free online courses from start to finish

    Thousands of online courses in video, ebooks and audiobooks.

  • More than 60 thousand free exercises

    To test your knowledge during online courses

  • Valid free Digital Certificate with QR Code

    Generated directly from your cell phone's photo gallery and sent to your email

Cursa app on the ebook screen, the video course screen and the course exercises screen, plus the course completion certificate