Why Subgrade and Base Prep Matters
A concrete slab, pad, or walkway is only as stable as what supports it. Concrete is strong in compression but cracks when parts of the slab lose support (settlement) or when water and freeze/thaw cycles create uneven movement. Good subgrade and base preparation aims to create a uniform, well-draining, well-compacted platform so the slab is supported evenly across its entire footprint.
How Unsuitable Soils Lead to Settlement and Cracking
- Organic topsoil (dark, loamy, root-filled): compresses and decomposes over time. As organics break down, voids form and the slab settles, often creating cracks and low spots.
- Clay soils: hold water, drain slowly, and can expand when wet and shrink when dry. This seasonal movement can lift or drop sections of a slab, causing cracking and uneven surfaces.
- Sandy soils: drain well but can be loose and prone to erosion or displacement if not compacted. Water can wash fines away, creating voids.
- Fill soils (previously disturbed): may be layered, inconsistent, and under-compacted. Differential settlement is common unless properly reworked and compacted in lifts.
Evaluating Soil Conditions On Site
Quick Field Checks You Can Do
- Visual and smell test: topsoil is dark and often smells “earthy”; it contains roots and plant matter. Remove it completely under concrete.
- Hand squeeze test (moist soil): grab a handful and squeeze. Clay forms a sticky ball and can be rolled into a ribbon; sand falls apart and feels gritty; silt feels smooth like flour and can hold shape but isn’t sticky.
- Probe test: push a steel rod, stake, or screwdriver into the ground. Sudden easy penetration indicates soft/loose zones that may need deeper excavation, stabilization, or geotextile.
- Puddle/soak observation: after rain or a hose test, note where water stands. Slow-draining areas often indicate clay or a low spot that will trap water under the slab.
Deciding What “Good Enough” Looks Like
For small projects, your goal is uniform support. If the soil is consistent, firm underfoot, and doesn’t pump water when stepped on, it may serve as subgrade after proper trimming and compaction. If it is organic, spongy, muddy, or highly variable, plan on removal and replacement with a compacted granular base (and possibly geotextile).
Step-by-Step Excavation and Grade Planning
1) Define the Finished Surface and Drainage Direction
Before digging, decide where water should go. For walkways and pads, plan a slope that sheds water away from structures and avoids low spots that will pond.
- Typical slope target: 1/8 in per ft (about 1%) minimum; 1/4 in per ft (about 2%) is common for exterior flatwork that needs reliable drainage.
- Away from structures: slope away from foundations, garages, and sheds so runoff doesn’t collect at the wall.
2) Calculate Target Excavation Depth
Excavation depth is based on the planned concrete thickness plus base thickness (if used), plus any bedding layers (fabric doesn’t add thickness; vapor barrier is thin but must be accounted for in placement).
| Example | Concrete | Base | Total Excavation Below Finished Grade |
|---|---|---|---|
| Walkway (typical) | 4 in | 4 in compacted granular base | ~8 in |
| Small pad (light loads) | 4 in | 4–6 in base (as needed) | ~8–10 in |
| Good native granular soil (best case) | 4 in | 0–3 in leveling base (optional) | ~4–7 in |
Note: If you must remove soft/organic material deeper than planned, you may end up excavating more and replacing with compacted base to reach the correct finished elevation.
Continue in our app.
You can listen to the audiobook with the screen off, receive a free certificate for this course, and also have access to 5,000 other free online courses.
Or continue reading below...Download the app
3) Remove Organic Material Completely
- Strip all topsoil, sod, mulch, roots, and buried wood from the slab footprint and a little beyond the edges (commonly 6–12 in) so the perimeter isn’t sitting on organics.
- Remove any soft pockets until you reach firm material. If you keep finding roots/organics, keep going—leaving them behind is a common cause of edge settlement.
4) Aim for Undisturbed Soil When Possible
Undisturbed soil (soil that hasn’t been previously dug and backfilled) is typically more stable than fill. If you can excavate down to firm undisturbed soil, you reduce settlement risk. If the site is already fill, treat it as suspect: rework, moisture-condition, and compact in lifts, or over-excavate and replace with a compacted granular base.
5) Trim the Subgrade to Match the Planned Slope
- Shape the subgrade so it generally follows the finished slope. This helps keep base thickness consistent and prevents thin spots.
- Avoid “dishes” that can trap water under the slab. If the subgrade has a low bowl, water can collect there even if the top surface drains.
Base Material Selection and When You Need a Granular Base
Common Base Options
- Crusher run / road base (well-graded with fines): compacts tightly and locks together. Good for most slabs and walkways. The fines help it “bind,” but it can hold water if drainage is poor.
- Clean crushed gravel (open-graded, minimal fines): drains very well and works as a capillary break. It can be harder to “finish flat” and may need careful compaction and leveling.
- Pea gravel: rounded and tends to roll; generally not ideal as a structural base because it doesn’t lock together well.
When a Granular Base Is Required (or Strongly Recommended)
- Clay or poorly draining soils: a granular base improves drainage and provides a stable working platform.
- Any area with organics removed or soft pockets: replacement with compacted base restores uniform support.
- Fill or disturbed ground: base helps bridge minor variability and provides consistent support.
- Freeze/thaw climates: a draining base reduces water retention under the slab, lowering frost-related movement risk.
- When you need to raise grade: base is the correct way to build up elevation (in compacted lifts), not loose soil.
If the native soil is firm, granular, and drains well, you may use a thinner base mainly for leveling. If the soil is variable, wet, or fine-grained, plan on a thicker granular base and consider geotextile separation.
Compaction: How to Build a Stable Platform
Key Concepts: Lifts, Moisture, and Uniformity
- Compact in lifts: place base in layers so the compactor can densify the full thickness. Overly thick lifts compact on top but stay loose below.
- Moisture conditioning: base compacts best when slightly damp. Too dry won’t knit together; too wet will pump and rut.
- Uniform compaction: inconsistent compaction causes differential settlement—one of the most common reasons for random cracking.
Practical Lift Thickness Guidelines
- Plate compactor (common for small projects): often works best with ~2–4 in lifts depending on material and machine size.
- Hand tamper: limited effectiveness; keep lifts thinner (often ~1–2 in) and expect more effort and less uniform results.
- Jumping jack / rammer: effective in cohesive soils and confined areas; still compact in manageable lifts.
When in doubt, use thinner lifts. It takes longer but reduces the chance of a hidden soft layer.
Moisture Conditioning: What “Right” Looks Like
- Too dry: dusty, won’t bind, compactor “skips” and the surface ravels.
- Too wet: shiny/wet surface, pumping or rippling under the compactor, deep footprints, and rutting.
- About right: slightly damp, compacts to a firm surface with minimal loose aggregate on top.
If it’s too dry, lightly mist and mix before compacting. If it’s too wet, let it dry and rework; compacting wet base often locks in instability.
Compaction Pattern: How to Cover the Area Evenly
- Compact the perimeter first to stabilize edges, then work inward.
- Make overlapping passes (think “mowing the lawn”): each pass overlaps the previous by about 1/3 of the machine width.
- Change direction: compact north-south, then east-west to reduce directional weak spots.
- Pay extra attention to edges, corners, and around penetrations where compaction is often missed.
Verifying Compaction Without Lab Tests
Professional work may use density testing, but small projects can use practical checks to catch obvious problems.
- Footprint test: walk across the compacted base. You should not leave deep prints. A slight scuff is normal; sinking indicates more compaction or moisture correction is needed.
- Probe resistance: push a rod or stake into the base. Resistance should feel consistent across the area. Easy penetration in one zone suggests a soft pocket or thicker, under-compacted lift.
- Uniformity check: scrape the surface lightly with a rake. If one area loosens easily while others stay tight, that area likely needs more compaction or moisture adjustment.
- Plate “bounce” feel: as compaction improves, the plate compactor tends to ride higher and feel more responsive; if it bogs down in one area, investigate moisture or soft subgrade.
Drainage Fundamentals Under and Around Slabs
Surface Slope Targets
- Walkways: commonly 1/4 in per ft for reliable drainage; 1/8 in per ft minimum if constraints exist.
- Pads: 1/8–1/4 in per ft depending on use; aim to prevent ponding and keep water away from structures.
Directing Water Away From Structures
- Ensure the finished concrete surface slopes away from foundations and door thresholds.
- Plan where runoff will go: to a yard area that can absorb it, a swale, or a drain path—without sending water to a neighbor or back toward the building.
Avoiding Trapped Water Under Slabs
- Don’t create a “bathtub”: if the excavation is deeper at the edges and higher in the middle, water can collect under the slab.
- Use draining layers where needed: clean gravel can help water move away rather than sit against the underside of the concrete.
- Watch downspouts and irrigation: keep them from discharging next to slabs where water can infiltrate and soften subgrade.
Optional Elements for Problem Soils and Moisture Control
Geotextile Fabric (Separation and Stabilization)
Geotextile is a permeable fabric placed between weak subgrade and granular base. It helps keep base stone from sinking into soft soil and prevents soil fines from migrating up into the base.
- When to use: soft or silty subgrades, variable soils, areas that stay wet, or when you see “pumping” under foot traffic or equipment.
- How to install: place directly on trimmed subgrade, overlap seams (commonly 12–24 in), and extend beyond slab edges. Place base on top without driving directly on exposed fabric if it can tear.
- Common mistakes: not overlapping seams, leaving wrinkles that create uneven base thickness, tearing the fabric with sharp turns or dumping rock from too high, and using fabric as a “fix” without removing organics.
Capillary Breaks (Reducing Moisture Wicking)
A capillary break is a layer that interrupts water wicking upward from wet soil into the slab. Clean, open-graded crushed stone is commonly used because it has larger voids that reduce capillary rise.
- When to use: damp sites, clay soils, areas with high groundwater, or when moisture-sensitive flooring/finishes may be installed later.
- Typical approach: a layer of clean crushed stone beneath the slab (often several inches), compacted and leveled.
- Common mistakes: using material with too many fines (which can wick water), failing to keep the layer uniform thickness, and allowing soil to contaminate the stone (geotextile can help).
Vapor Barriers (Moisture Vapor Control)
A vapor barrier is a plastic sheet intended to reduce moisture vapor moving up through the slab. It is especially relevant for slabs that will be enclosed or finished.
- When to use: interior slabs, slabs under conditioned spaces, or any slab that may later receive flooring, adhesives, or coatings sensitive to moisture.
- Placement basics: install over a smooth, compacted base; overlap seams and tape them; seal around penetrations.
- Common mistakes: puncturing it during rebar/chair placement or traffic, failing to tape seams, leaving gaps at edges, placing it over a rough base that tears it, and trapping water by installing it over muddy subgrade (the base should be stable and not saturated).
Putting It Together: A Practical Workflow for Small Slabs and Walkways
1) Identify drainage direction and set a slope target (1–2%). 2) Mark finished height and calculate excavation depth (concrete + base). 3) Excavate and remove all organics/roots; over-excavate soft pockets. 4) Trim subgrade to approximate slope; eliminate bowls that trap water. 5) If soil is weak/wet/silty, place geotextile with proper overlaps. 6) Place base in thin lifts (2–4 in typical), moisture-condition, and compact with overlapping passes. 7) Verify compaction with footprint/probe/uniformity checks; fix soft areas now. 8) Final-grade the base to consistent thickness and planned slope; keep it clean and undisturbed.