Putting It All Together: Multi-Concept Problem Solving with Units and Common Pitfalls

1) A Consistent Multi-Concept Problem-Solving Template

When problems combine kinematics, forces, energy, momentum, and rotation, the main difficulty is not the math—it is choosing a clean path and keeping signs, components, and units consistent. Use the same template every time so you do not “forget” a concept or apply one twice.

Step A — Diagram (and a coordinate choice)

• Sketch the situation with key distances, angles, and motion directions.
• Choose axes and state them explicitly (e.g., +x along the incline, +y perpendicular to the surface).
• Mark where you will apply each principle (before/after collision, start/end of motion, top/bottom of swing).

Step B — Knowns/Unknowns (with units)

Write a short list of given quantities and what you must find. Put units next to every number immediately. If a quantity is missing units, do not proceed until you supply them.

Step C — Principles (choose the minimal set)

Pick the smallest set of principles that can connect your knowns to your unknowns:

• Forces/Newton (component equations) when acceleration or contact forces are central.
• Energy when you care about speeds/heights without needing time.
• Momentum/Impulse for short interactions (collisions, pushes) where external impulse is negligible.
• Rotation when rolling, torques, or angular speed matters.

Step D — Equations (write before plugging numbers)

Write symbolic equations first. Only then substitute numbers. This makes unit checks and sign checks easier.

Step E — Solve (algebra first, then arithmetic)

Isolate the target variable symbolically. Then compute. Keep 2–4 significant figures unless the problem demands otherwise.

Continue in our app.

• Listen to the audio with the screen off.
• Earn a certificate upon completion.
• Over 5000 courses for you to explore!

Or continue reading below...

Download the app

Step F — Sanity checks (units, limits, sign, magnitude)

• Units: every term in an equation must have the same units; your final answer must match the requested unit.
• Limits: test extreme cases (e.g., friction → 0, angle → 0, mass → very large).
• Sign: does the sign match your axis choice and physical direction?
• Magnitude: is the value plausible (e.g., a car speed of 300 m/s on a city turn is not)?

2) Mixed Scenarios (Structured Case Studies)

Case Study A — Block–Spring with Kinetic Friction (Energy + Forces + Units)

Scenario: A block of mass m slides on a horizontal surface with kinetic friction coefficient μ_k. It hits a spring (spring constant k) and compresses it by x before momentarily stopping. The block’s speed just before contacting the spring is v_0. Find the maximum compression x.

Template Walkthrough

A) Diagram: Horizontal surface, block moving right, spring at the right. Choose +x to the right. Friction acts left during compression.

B) Knowns/Unknowns: m (kg), μ_k (unitless), k (N/m), v_0 (m/s), g (m/s^2). Unknown: x (m).

C) Principles: Use work–energy with nonconservative work by friction.

D) Equations:

Initial kinetic energy becomes spring potential energy plus energy dissipated by friction:

(1/2) m v_0^2 = (1/2) k x^2 + W_f

For kinetic friction on a horizontal surface: f_k = μ_k N = μ_k m g. During compression, friction does negative work: W_f = f_k x = μ_k m g x (this is the magnitude; it appears with a plus sign on the right because it is energy “spent”).

So:

(1/2) m v_0^2 = (1/2) k x^2 + μ_k m g x

E) Solve: This is a quadratic in x:

(1/2) k x^2 + (μ_k m g) x - (1/2) m v_0^2 = 0

Multiply by 2:

k x^2 + 2 μ_k m g x - m v_0^2 = 0

Use the quadratic formula:

x = [ -2 μ_k m g + sqrt( (2 μ_k m g)^2 + 4 k m v_0^2 ) ] / (2k)

Choose the positive root (compression must be positive):

x = [ -2 μ_k m g + sqrt( 4 μ_k^2 m^2 g^2 + 4 k m v_0^2 ) ] / (2k)

Simplify:

x = [ - μ_k m g + sqrt( μ_k^2 m^2 g^2 + k m v_0^2 ) ] / k

F) Sanity checks:

• Units: numerator has N (since m g is N) and the square root also yields N; dividing by k (N/m) gives meters.
• Limit μ_k → 0: x → sqrt(m/k) v_0, matching frictionless energy conversion.
• Limit k → very large: compression becomes small.

Common pitfall inside this scenario

Putting friction work as -μ_k m g x on the right side while also writing “energy lost” separately. Decide one convention: either include friction as a negative work term on the left, or as a positive “dissipated energy” term on the right—do not double-count.

Case Study B — Car on a Banked Turn with Energy Considerations (Forces + Circular Motion + Energy)

Scenario: A car enters a banked curve of radius R at speed v_1 and exits at speed v_2 due to braking. The road is banked at angle θ. Assume the car stays in contact without slipping. Determine whether the required friction is up-slope or down-slope at entry and at exit, and write an expression for the needed friction magnitude in terms of v (treat v as a variable). Then connect v_1 to v_2 using energy with braking work.

Template Walkthrough

A) Diagram: Cross-section of bank: normal force N perpendicular to road, weight mg downward, friction f along the surface. Choose axes: radial inward (horizontal toward center) and vertical.

B) Knowns/Unknowns: m, R, θ, v_1, v_2, and possibly braking work W_brake (J) or braking force over distance.

C) Principles: Use force components for centripetal acceleration; use energy to relate speeds if braking work is specified.

D) Equations (force balance with centripetal requirement):

Let inward radial direction be positive. The car needs inward acceleration a_c = v^2/R.

Resolve N into components: inward component N sinθ, upward component N cosθ.

Friction direction depends on whether the car’s speed is above or below the “no-friction” design speed. Write equations using a sign convention: take friction positive if it points up the slope (which contributes inward and downward components depending on geometry). Along the surface, friction is parallel to the road; its components are: inward f cosθ (if up-slope, it points more inward), and vertical -f sinθ (up-slope friction has a downward vertical component).

Then:

Inward: N sinθ + f cosθ = m v^2 / R

Vertical: N cosθ - f sinθ = m g

Solve these simultaneously for f as a function of v:

From vertical: N = (m g + f sinθ)/cosθ

Substitute into inward:

(m g + f sinθ) tanθ + f cosθ = m v^2 / R

m g tanθ + f (sinθ tanθ + cosθ) = m v^2 / R

Use sinθ tanθ = sin^2θ / cosθ and cosθ = cos^2θ / cosθ, so:

sinθ tanθ + cosθ = (sin^2θ + cos^2θ)/cosθ = 1/cosθ

Therefore:

m g tanθ + f (1/cosθ) = m v^2 / R

f = cosθ [ m v^2 / R - m g tanθ ]

f = m cosθ ( v^2 / R - g tanθ )

Direction logic:

• If f > 0, friction is up-slope (by our sign convention).
• If f < 0, friction is down-slope (opposite direction).

The “no-friction” speed occurs when f = 0:

v_0 = sqrt(R g tanθ)

So:

• If v > v_0, then v^2/R is too large; friction must help provide extra inward force → f > 0 (up-slope).
• If v < v_0, friction must oppose the tendency to slide down the bank → f < 0 (down-slope).

E) Energy link (braking): If braking does work W_brake (negative), then:

(1/2) m v_2^2 = (1/2) m v_1^2 + W_brake

If braking force magnitude F_b acts over arc length s, then W_brake = -F_b s. If the car travels a quarter-circle, s = (π/2) R. Use the given geometry.

F) Sanity checks:

• Units: f expression gives kg * (m/s^2) = N.
• Limit θ → 0: tanθ → 0, cosθ → 1, so f ≈ m v^2/R, meaning friction supplies centripetal force on a flat road.

Case Study C — Pendulum-Like Swing (Energy + Tension + “Where to Use Newton”)

Scenario: A person on a rope swing (length L) starts from rest at an angle θ_0 from vertical and swings down. Find the speed at the bottom and the tension in the rope at the bottom.

Template Walkthrough

A) Diagram: Rope of length L, pivot at top. Mark initial position at angle θ_0. Bottom position is vertical.

B) Knowns/Unknowns: m, L, θ_0, g. Unknowns: v_bottom, T_bottom.

C) Principles: Use energy for speed; use Newton’s 2nd law radially for tension.

D) Equations (energy): Height drop from initial to bottom is:

h = L(1 - cosθ_0)

Energy conversion:

m g h = (1/2) m v^2

So:

v_bottom = sqrt(2 g L (1 - cosθ_0))

D) Equations (tension at bottom): At bottom, radial inward direction is upward along the rope. Forces along the rope: tension T upward, weight mg downward. Net inward force provides centripetal acceleration:

T - m g = m v^2 / L

E) Solve:

T_bottom = m g + m v_bottom^2 / L

Substitute v_bottom:

T_bottom = m g + m [2 g L (1 - cosθ_0)] / L = m g [1 + 2(1 - cosθ_0)]

T_bottom = m g (3 - 2 cosθ_0)

F) Sanity checks:

• Units: tension in newtons.
• Limit θ_0 → 0: cosθ_0 → 1 gives v → 0 and T → mg, correct for hanging at rest.
• Magnitude: tension should exceed mg when moving through the bottom (extra centripetal requirement).

Common pitfall inside this scenario

Using energy to compute tension directly. Energy gives speed; tension requires a force equation because tension depends on instantaneous acceleration direction (centripetal) even when speed is known.

Case Study D — Rolling Object Collides with Another Object (Rotation + Momentum, Qualitative with Key Equations)

Scenario: A solid cylinder (mass m, radius R) rolls without slipping with speed v and hits a stationary block (mass M) on a horizontal surface. The collision is brief. Discuss what can and cannot be conserved, and outline a solvable approach depending on collision details.

Template Walkthrough

A) Diagram: Cylinder moving right, block at rest. Contact forces during collision are large and short-lived. There may be friction impulses at the ground and at the contact point.

B) Knowns/Unknowns: m, M, v, R. Unknowns depend on collision type: final speeds, whether rolling continues, possible slipping, etc.

C) Principles (choose carefully):

• Linear momentum of the two-object system is conserved only if external impulse in the horizontal direction is negligible during the collision. Ground friction can provide an external impulse, so you must justify neglecting it (e.g., “very short collision, small ground impulse”).
• Angular momentum about a carefully chosen point may be approximately conserved if external torques about that point are negligible during the collision. Choosing the contact point with the ground can sometimes eliminate unknown ground friction torque, but the block contact may still exert torque.
• Mechanical energy is generally not conserved in collisions (unless explicitly elastic). Rolling kinetic energy includes translation and rotation: K = (1/2) m v^2 + (1/2) I ω^2 with v = ωR for rolling without slipping.

Key equations you may need

• Rolling cylinder moment of inertia: I = (1/2) m R^2.
• Rolling relation (if it holds before/after): v = ωR.
• Total initial kinetic energy of rolling cylinder: K_i = (1/2) m v^2 + (1/2)(1/2 m R^2)(v^2/R^2) = (3/4) m v^2.

Two common modeling routes

Route 1: “Ignore ground impulse during collision” approximation

• Assume horizontal external impulse from ground friction is negligible during the short collision.
• Then linear momentum of cylinder+block in the horizontal direction is approximately conserved during the impact interval.
• You still need a collision model (elastic, perfectly inelastic, coefficient of restitution) to close the system.

Route 2: “After-collision rolling adjustment”

• Even if the collision gives the cylinder some new translational speed v' and angular speed ω', it may not satisfy v' = ω'R immediately.
• Then, after the collision, static/kinetic friction with the ground acts over a longer time to restore rolling without slipping, dissipating energy if slipping occurs.
• This separates the problem into two phases: (i) impulsive collision (momentum/impulse), (ii) post-collision rolling/slipping evolution (forces + energy dissipation).

Sanity checks

• If you predict an increase in total mechanical energy in an inelastic collision without an external energy source, something is wrong.
• If you assume “momentum conserved” while also using a large ground friction impulse to enforce rolling during the collision, you are mixing incompatible assumptions.

3) Common Misconceptions and How to Detect Them

Misconception 1 — Incorrect force pairs (Newton’s 3rd law)

What goes wrong: Treating two forces on the same object as an action–reaction pair (e.g., “normal force and weight are a 3rd-law pair”).

Detection test: A 3rd-law pair must act on different objects. If both forces are on the same free-body diagram, they are not a 3rd-law pair.

Fix: When you write a 3rd-law pair, name both objects: “Earth on block” and “block on Earth,” or “road on tire” and “tire on road.”

Misconception 2 — Wrong friction direction

What goes wrong: Assuming friction always opposes motion, rather than opposing relative slipping (or attempted slipping) at the contact.

Detection test: Ask: “If there were no friction, which way would the surfaces slip relative to each other?” Friction points opposite that slip direction.

Fix: For rolling problems, decide whether the contact point tends to slip forward or backward. For blocks, decide whether the block tends to move relative to the surface.

Misconception 3 — Mixing radians and degrees in rotation

What goes wrong: Using degrees directly in formulas that require radians (especially s = rθ, v = rω, a_t = rα, and rotational energy relations involving ω).

Detection test: Unit check: angles in these relations are dimensionless but must be in radians. If you plug 90 instead of π/2, your arc length becomes 57.3× too large.

Fix: Convert early: θ(rad) = θ(deg) × π/180. Keep a note near your equations: θ in rad.

Misconception 4 — Treating g as negative without stating axes

What goes wrong: Writing g = -9.8 in one line and g = +9.8 in another, causing sign flips in energy or kinematics.

Detection test: If your final speed becomes imaginary or your acceleration changes sign mid-problem, check whether you silently changed axis direction.

Fix: Use g = 9.8 m/s^2 as a magnitude, and put the sign in the component equation (e.g., a_y = -g if +y is upward).

Misconception 5 — Ignoring vector components

What goes wrong: Treating vector equations as scalar without projecting onto axes (common in 2D momentum, banked turns, and angled forces).

Detection test: If an equation adds quantities pointing in different directions (e.g., adding mv values without components), it is invalid.

Fix: Write component equations explicitly: ΣF_x = ma_x, p_x conserved separately from p_y when appropriate, and keep a sign convention for each axis.

4) End-of-Course Skills Checklist + Cumulative Practice Problems

Skills checklist (what you should be able to do reliably)

• Translate a word problem into a diagram with a declared coordinate system.
• List knowns/unknowns with correct SI units and identify missing information.
• Select an efficient principle set (forces vs energy vs momentum vs rotation) and justify why it applies in each phase.
• Write correct component equations and avoid mixing scalars and vectors.
• Carry units through algebra and use unit consistency to catch mistakes early.
• Use limiting-case checks (friction → 0, angle → 0, mass ratio extremes) to validate results.
• Interpret results in real-world terms (direction, feasibility, approximate magnitude).

Cumulative practice problems (organized by concept combinations)

Instructions for all problems: (i) Use the template: diagram → knowns/unknowns → principles → equations → solve → sanity checks. (ii) Show at least one explicit unit check in your solution. (iii) Interpret your final result in a sentence (what it means physically).

A) Kinematics + Forces (with components)

• Problem A1: A crate is pulled up a ramp at constant speed by a rope at angle φ above the ramp surface. Given m, ramp angle θ, and μ_k, find the required rope tension. Include a check that your tension reduces correctly when μ_k → 0.
• Problem A2: A drone accelerates horizontally while carrying a mass on a string. Given acceleration a, find the string angle from vertical and the tension. State your axis choice and keep g as a magnitude.

B) Energy + Forces (nonconservative work)

• Problem B1: A sled of mass m slides down a hill of height h then across a rough flat region (coefficient μ_k) and stops. Find the stopping distance on the flat. Unit-check the distance.
• Problem B2: A spring launcher fires a puck across a rough surface. Given k, compression x, μ_k, and m, find the maximum distance traveled before stopping. Interpret how doubling x changes the distance.

C) Circular motion + Forces + Energy

• Problem C1: A car enters a banked turn (radius R, bank angle θ) at speed v_1 and brakes with constant braking force magnitude F_b over arc length s. Find the friction direction at entry and exit, and compute the required friction magnitude at exit. Include a unit check for F_b s.
• Problem C2: A bead slides on a vertical circular track of radius R with negligible friction. Starting from rest at height h above the bottom, find the speed at the top and the condition on h for maintaining contact. State clearly where you use energy and where you use forces.

D) Momentum + Energy (two-stage problems)

• Problem D1: A moving cart collides and sticks to a stationary cart (perfectly inelastic). After collision, the combined cart compresses a spring and stops. Given masses, initial speed, and k, find maximum compression. Identify the stage where momentum applies and the stage where energy applies, and unit-check your compression.
• Problem D2: A ball hits a wall and rebounds with known coefficient of restitution e. Given incoming speed and angle, find outgoing speed components and impulse magnitude. Include a vector-component check.

E) Rotation + Energy + Rolling constraints

• Problem E1: A solid sphere rolls without slipping down a height h. Find its speed at the bottom. Then compare to a sliding block from the same height. Interpret the difference in terms of energy partitioning.
• Problem E2: A rolling cylinder goes up an incline without slipping and comes to rest. Given initial speed v and incline angle θ, find the maximum vertical rise. Include a limit check: if the object were not rotating, what would change?

F) Rotation + Momentum (collisions involving spin)

• Problem F1 (qualitative + setup): A rolling disk hits a stationary disk in a glancing collision. List which quantities are conserved (or not) under (i) negligible external impulse and torque, (ii) significant ground friction impulse. For each case, write the conservation equations you would start with and state what extra information is needed to solve numerically.
• Problem F2: A rod pivoted at one end is struck by a small projectile that sticks at distance r from the pivot. Given projectile mass and speed, rod mass and length, find the immediate angular speed after impact. Perform an explicit unit check on angular speed (rad/s).