Why “more blending” often makes art look worse
Blending is not a default finishing step. It is a targeted tool for controlling edges (how sharply one shape/value transitions into another) and for describing surface quality (skin vs. metal vs. fabric). Over-blending usually causes three problems: (1) values become muddy because midtones spread everywhere, (2) forms lose structure because edges all become equally soft, and (3) focal points weaken because nothing looks intentional.
A useful mindset: paint edges, not gradients. Decide which edges should be hard, soft, or lost, then blend only where that decision supports the form and the focus.
Edge control: hard, soft, and lost edges
Hard edges (crisp transitions)
Hard edges communicate clarity and draw attention. Use them for: the silhouette of the subject, key overlaps (one form in front of another), sharp cast shadows, and small high-contrast details near the focal point (eyes, emblem, weapon edge, etc.).
- Keep hard edges where you want the viewer to look first.
- Keep hard edges where the form changes abruptly (fold creases, object corners, contact shadows).
Soft edges (gradual transitions)
Soft edges suggest roundness, atmospheric softness, or gentle light falloff. Use them for: turning planes on a sphere-like form, soft shadow transitions, and areas away from the focal point.
- Soften edges on curved forms (cheeks, arms, rounded props).
- Soften edges in secondary areas to reduce visual noise.
Lost edges (edges that disappear)
A lost edge happens when two adjacent shapes share similar value and/or color, so the boundary fades. This is powerful for grouping shapes and creating depth, but it must be intentional.
- Listen to the audio with the screen off.
- Earn a certificate upon completion.
- Over 5000 courses for you to explore!
Download the app
- Lose edges in shadow masses where forms merge.
- Lose edges where you want the viewer to skip over an area.
A simple focus rule
In most illustrations, aim for: sharpest edges + highest contrast near the focal point, and progressively softer edges and lower contrast as you move away. This can be done even if your lineart stays crisp—edge control can happen inside the paint shapes and values.
Three blending approaches in Krita (and when to use each)
1) Smudge brushes (push pixels)
Smudge brushes physically drag existing paint. They are great for subtle transitions, but they can quickly create “plastic” surfaces if used everywhere.
- Best for: small edge adjustments, softening a shadow boundary on a rounded form, pulling a little color into another to unify.
- Avoid for: large-area blending across many values (this often muddies).
Controlled method: use short strokes that follow the form (wrap around a cylinder, arc around a sphere). If you smudge back-and-forth in a straight line, you flatten the form.
2) Blender presets (mix paint more predictably)
Blender presets are designed to mix without destroying texture as aggressively as a generic smudge. Think of them as “mixing brushes” rather than “finger smears.”
- Best for: smoothing transitions while keeping some brush character, especially on skin, soft fabric, or painterly styles.
- Tip: keep your strokes directional and limited to the transition zone (the edge), not the entire area.
3) Low-opacity painting as blending (the cleanest option)
Instead of smearing existing pixels, you can blend by painting intermediate values with a normal brush at low opacity/flow. This is often the most controllable method because you decide exactly what color/value is added.
- Best for: maintaining clean color relationships, preserving texture, and avoiding muddy midtones.
- How it feels: you “build” the gradient with deliberate strokes rather than smudging.
Practical tip: sample the two neighboring colors/values and paint a middle step between them. Repeat with smaller steps only where needed. This keeps the transition intentional and prevents overworking.
Step-by-step: a repeatable edge-control mini study (sphere + cube)
This routine trains you to decide edges first, blend second. Keep it small (300–600 px wide) so you don’t over-render.
Step 1: Set up three value zones
- Create a sphere and a cube on a neutral mid-gray background.
- Block in: light, mid, and shadow as simple shapes (no blending yet).
- Add a cast shadow shape under each object.
Step 2: Label your edges (mentally)
Before blending, decide:
- Hard: cube corners, contact shadow under the cube/sphere, the far edge of cast shadow.
- Soft: sphere’s terminator transition (light to shadow), soft falloff inside the cast shadow.
- Lost: optional—merge part of the shadow side into the background by matching value slightly.
Step 3: Blend only the edges that are meant to be soft
- On the sphere, soften the light-to-shadow transition with either a blender preset or low-opacity painting. Keep the highlight edge relatively crisp if you want a shinier look; soften it for matte.
- On the cube, keep plane changes mostly hard. Only soften slightly if the material is soft (e.g., foam) or the lighting is very diffuse.
Step 4: Check readability at a glance
Zoom out until the objects are thumbnail-sized. If the cube looks round or the sphere looks faceted, you blended the wrong edges. Undo or repaint those edges with a firmer transition.
Texture without over-smearing: controlled grain and brush variation
Texture has a job
Texture should support: (1) material identity (cloth vs. stone), (2) form (wraps around the surface), and (3) hierarchy (less texture in focal areas if it competes with details, or more texture if it enhances the focal material).
Method A: Add grain subtly (unifying texture)
Use a lightly textured brush at low opacity to introduce a consistent grain across an area. This helps prevent “airbrushed” patches after blending.
- Where: large midtone areas (skin, walls, sky gradients) that look too smooth.
- How: paint gently in the direction of the form; avoid random scribbling that ignores volume.
Method B: Use textured brushes for variation (local texture)
Instead of blending everything smooth, let a textured brush create natural variation while you paint. This gives you “free” surface detail without extra steps.
- Cloth: texture strokes should follow folds and stretch direction.
- Wood/stone: texture can be more irregular, but still should respect perspective and plane changes.
- Skin: keep texture extremely subtle; prioritize value and edge control.
Method C: Keep texture consistent with form (the key rule)
Texture must wrap. On a cylinder-like arm, texture strokes should curve around the arm. On a cube, texture should change direction per plane. If texture direction stays the same everywhere, the object looks flat even if the shading is correct.
| Form | Texture direction guideline | Common mistake |
|---|---|---|
| Sphere | Arcing strokes that follow roundness | Straight smears that flatten |
| Cube | Different stroke direction per plane | One-direction texture across corners |
| Cylinder | Wrap-around strokes + lengthwise accents | Only lengthwise strokes (looks flat) |
Selective blending workflow on a main illustration (preserve lineart and clarity)
Step 1: Identify your “no-blend zones”
Pick 3–5 areas that must stay crisp for readability (often: facial features, hands, key prop edges, silhouette breaks). These areas get minimal smudge blending. You can still soften within the paint, but keep transitions controlled and avoid dragging across important boundaries.
Step 2: Blend in the transition band only
For each soft edge, imagine a narrow band where the transition happens. Blend inside that band and stop. If you blend beyond it, you erase structure.
- On a cheek: blend the terminator zone, not the entire cheek.
- On a cast shadow: soften the inner shadow, keep the contact edge firm.
Step 3: Prefer low-opacity painting for big areas
For large gradients (arms, torso, background shapes), use low-opacity painting to build smoothness while keeping brush texture. Reserve smudge/blender tools for small corrections and edge tuning.
Step 4: Re-introduce texture after blending
If blending made an area too slick, add controlled texture back:
- Use a textured brush at low opacity to stipple or lightly stroke over midtones.
- Keep texture weaker near focal details if it competes with lineart.
- Strengthen texture on secondary materials (clothing, background props) to add interest without stealing focus.
Step 5: Edge hierarchy pass (fast checklist)
- Focal point: sharper edges, clearer value separation, selective texture.
- Mid-importance areas: a mix of hard and soft edges, moderate texture.
- Low-importance areas: softer edges, fewer high-contrast details, simplified texture.
Practice routine (15–25 minutes) to build the habit
Part A: 8 minutes — sphere/cube edge drill
- 2 minutes: block 3 values + cast shadows.
- 3 minutes: soften only the sphere’s turning edge; keep cube planes crisp.
- 3 minutes: add subtle texture that follows form (wrap on sphere, plane-based on cube).
Part B: 12–17 minutes — apply to your illustration
- 3 minutes: mark focal area and “no-blend zones.”
- 5 minutes: selective blending on soft edges only (transition bands).
- 4 minutes: texture pass (grain + material-specific texture) while respecting form.
- Optional 2–5 minutes: zoomed-out readability check; restore any edges that got too soft by repainting a crisp boundary.
Common fixes when things go wrong
- Looks muddy: stop smudging; repaint clean value shapes, then blend with low-opacity painting.
- Everything looks equally soft: reintroduce a few hard edges at overlaps and focal details.
- Texture looks pasted on: change texture direction per plane and reduce texture contrast in shadow.
- Lineart feels buried: avoid blending across line boundaries; instead, blend within the color shapes and keep high-contrast edges where the line defines form.