Cost Drivers in Transportation: Rates, Accessorials, and Total Landed Cost

What “Transportation Cost” Really Includes

Transportation cost is more than the freight rate on a carrier invoice. A useful way to manage it is to separate carrier charges (what the carrier bills) from shipper-side costs (what you spend to prepare, execute, and administer the shipment). When you compare options, focus on total landed cost: the all-in cost to deliver product to the destination in the required condition and time window.

Core cost components

• Linehaul (base transportation): the main movement charge (per mile, per shipment, per hundredweight, per container, etc.).
• Fuel: a separate surcharge or embedded factor that changes with market fuel indices.
• Accessorial charges: fees for conditions outside “standard” pickup/delivery (detention, layover, lumper, re-delivery, residential, liftgate, appointment, limited access, inside delivery, etc.).
• Packaging and handling: pallets, dunnage, stretch wrap, cartons, labels, labor to pick/pack, and any special handling.
• Administrative costs: planning time, tendering, customer service touches, claims handling, invoice audit, and payment processing.

Linehaul: The Base Rate You Start With

Linehaul is the “headline” number people quote, but it is only one part of the bill. How linehaul is calculated depends on mode and pricing method.

Common linehaul structures

• Per-mile (often for truckload): Linehaul = Miles × Rate_per_mile
• Per-shipment (spot or contract): a flat amount for the move, sometimes with a fuel add-on.
• Per hundredweight (LTL): based on freight class, weight breaks, and lane.
• Per package (parcel): based on zone, billed weight, and service level.
• Per container (ocean): base ocean freight plus origin/destination charges and surcharges.
• Per kg (air): chargeable weight (actual vs volumetric) plus security/fuel and handling.

Fuel: Why It’s Often Separate

Fuel is frequently separated so carriers can adjust pricing as fuel markets change without renegotiating the base rate. Fuel can be:

• Index-based surcharge (common in TL/LTL/parcel): a table that maps fuel price to a percentage or cents-per-mile.
• Embedded in a flat rate (common in some spot quotes): simpler, but harder to compare across quotes.

Practical step: when comparing quotes, normalize fuel treatment. Convert everything to an “all-in transportation” number for the same assumed fuel index.

Accessorials: The Charges That Surprise Budgets

Accessorials are often the biggest source of variance between planned and actual cost. They are triggered by shipment characteristics, facility constraints, and execution issues (late loading, missing appointments, incorrect address, etc.).

Continue in our app.

• Listen to the audio with the screen off.
• Earn a certificate upon completion.
• Over 5000 courses for you to explore!

Or continue reading below...

Download the app

Common accessorials and what triggers them

• Detention: driver/trailer waiting beyond free time at pickup or delivery. Often billed per hour after a free-time threshold.
• Layover: driver is held overnight due to shipper/receiver delay; billed per day.
• Lumper: third-party labor required by some receivers to unload; billed as a pass-through or fixed fee.
• Re-delivery: delivery attempt fails (closed, refused, no appointment, wrong address) and must be re-attempted.
• Residential delivery: delivery to a home rather than a commercial dock; common in parcel and LTL.
• Liftgate: truck requires a liftgate to load/unload when no dock/forklift is available.

Practical step-by-step: reducing accessorial exposure

1. Map facility constraints: dock hours, appointment rules, unloading responsibility, lumper policy, equipment needs.
2. Validate addresses and contact info: especially for residential/limited-access locations.
3. Set realistic pickup/delivery windows: align order promise times with warehouse capacity.
4. Pre-advise special requirements: liftgate, inside delivery, call-ahead, appointment scheduling.
5. Measure dwell time: track arrival-to-departure timestamps and dispute incorrect detention.

Packaging and Handling: Hidden Cost and a Lever

Packaging affects cost in two ways: (1) direct spend on materials and labor, and (2) how the shipment is rated (size, weight, density, damage risk). Over-packaging increases cube and dimensional weight; under-packaging increases damage and claims.

Typical packaging/handling cost elements

• Cartons, pallets, corner boards, dunnage, stretch wrap, strapping
• Labor for pick/pack, palletizing, labeling, staging
• Special handling (fragile, hazmat packaging, temperature control materials)

Administrative Costs: Small per Shipment, Big in Aggregate

Administrative costs are easy to ignore because they are not always on the freight invoice. They matter most when shipment count is high (e.g., parcel) or when exceptions are frequent (re-deliveries, claims, invoice disputes).

Examples of administrative cost drivers

• Time to rate shop, tender, and track
• Customer service contacts for late/failed deliveries
• Invoice audit and accessorial validation
• Claims processing and chargebacks

How Pricing Differs by Mode (What to Look For)

Parcel: zone, billed weight, and surcharges

Parcel pricing typically depends on service level (ground/air), zone (distance-based), and billed weight (greater of actual and dimensional). Common add-ons include residential, delivery area surcharge, additional handling, oversize, and peak surcharges.

Key concept: a light but large box can cost more than a heavier compact box because of dimensional weight.

LTL: class-based rating and minimum charges

LTL linehaul is often based on freight class, which reflects density, stowability, handling, and liability. Pricing also uses weight breaks and can include minimum charges. Accessorials (liftgate, residential, appointment) are common.

Key concept: improving density (more weight per cubic foot) can reduce class and cost.

Truckload (TL): per-mile, per-load, and spot market dynamics

TL is commonly priced per mile or per load, with fuel and accessorials added. Spot rates can change quickly with capacity and seasonality. Detention and layover are frequent variance drivers.

Ocean and air: base rates plus surcharges and terminal/handling

International moves often have multiple layers: base freight plus surcharges (fuel, security, peak), plus origin/destination handling and terminal charges. Air is heavily influenced by chargeable weight (actual vs volumetric). Ocean can include container-related charges and port/terminal fees.

Shipment Design: How Your Choices Change the Bill

Shipment design is where transportation management can reduce cost without negotiating a single rate. The same demand can be shipped in ways that change billed weight, class, accessorial exposure, and damage risk.

Density and cube

• Parcel: reduce box size to reduce dimensional weight; avoid oversize thresholds.
• LTL: increase pallet density (better stacking, right-size cartons) to improve class.
• TL: avoid “shipping air” by improving cube utilization; reduce the number of loads.

Consolidation

Consolidation combines multiple orders into fewer shipments. It can reduce base transportation and admin costs, but may increase handling, dwell time, or inventory carrying cost if it delays shipping.

Equipment selection

Choosing the right equipment can prevent accessorials and rework:

• Liftgate truck vs standard trailer for non-dock deliveries
• Pup trailer vs 53-foot trailer for tight urban sites
• Temperature-controlled equipment when product risk is high

A Simple Cost Model You Can Use

Use a consistent model to compare options. Keep it simple enough to apply quickly, but complete enough to capture the big drivers.

Total Transportation Cost (TTC) = Linehaul + Fuel + Accessorials + Packaging/Handling + Admin

Then connect to landed cost:

Total Landed Cost (TLC) = TTC + Inventory/Service Impact + Damage/Claims Expected Cost + Other Delivery-Related Costs

Note: Inventory/service impact can be approximated when needed (e.g., expedited shipping avoided a stockout penalty; consolidation delayed delivery and increased backorders).

Worked Example 1: Parcel vs LTL for the Same Demand

Scenario: You need to ship 600 lb of product to one consignee. You can ship as 30 cartons (20 lb each) via parcel, or as 1 pallet via LTL. Destination is residential with no dock; liftgate likely needed for LTL.

Option A: Parcel (30 cartons)

Assumptions:

• Base parcel charge: $14 per carton
• Fuel surcharge: 12% of base
• Residential surcharge: $5 per carton
• Packaging: $0.80 per carton (materials)
• Handling labor: $0.60 per carton
• Admin: $0.50 per carton (high shipment count)

Step-by-step calculation:

• Base linehaul: 30 × $14 = $420
• Fuel: 12% × $420 = $50.40
• Residential: 30 × $5 = $150
• Packaging/handling: 30 × ($0.80 + $0.60) = $42
• Admin: 30 × $0.50 = $15

Total (Parcel TTC): $420 + $50.40 + $150 + $42 + $15 = $677.40

Option B: LTL (1 pallet)

Assumptions:

• LTL linehaul (class-rated): $320
• Fuel surcharge: 18% of linehaul
• Residential delivery: $85
• Liftgate: $65
• Appointment: $20
• Pallet + wrap: $18
• Handling labor: $12
• Admin: $6 per shipment

Step-by-step calculation:

• Linehaul: $320
• Fuel: 18% × $320 = $57.60
• Accessorials: $85 + $65 + $20 = $170
• Packaging/handling: $18 + $12 = $30
• Admin: $6

Total (LTL TTC): $320 + $57.60 + $170 + $30 + $6 = $583.60

Comparison: LTL is cheaper here by $93.80, even with residential + liftgate. However, if the receiver refuses pallets or cannot accept LTL deliveries reliably, re-delivery risk could erase the savings.

Worked Example 2: Lowest Freight Rate vs Lowest Total Cost (Detention and Re-delivery)

Scenario: A truckload shipment from DC to a customer site. Two carriers offer different base rates. The customer site is known for long unload times and missed appointments.

Assumptions for expected-cost comparison:

• Average unload time at site: 5 hours
• Probability of missed appointment leading to re-delivery: A = 10%, B = 4%
• Re-delivery charge if missed: $300
• Admin cost per exception (calls, reschedule, dispute): $40

Step-by-step: compute expected detention

• Carrier A detention hours: 5 - 2 = 3 hours billable → 3 × $85 = $255
• Carrier B detention hours: 5 - 4 = 1 hour billable → 1 × $85 = $85

Step-by-step: compute expected re-delivery and admin

• Carrier A expected re-delivery: 10% × $300 = $30
• Carrier B expected re-delivery: 4% × $300 = $12
• Carrier A expected admin: 10% × $40 = $4
• Carrier B expected admin: 4% × $40 = $1.60

Total expected transportation cost

• Carrier A: $1,850 + $250 + $255 + $30 + $4 = $2,389
• Carrier B: $2,050 + $250 + $85 + $12 + $1.60 = $2,398.60

Interpretation: Even after accounting for detention and expected exceptions, Carrier A remains slightly cheaper in this example. But the difference is only $9.60. If the customer penalizes late deliveries, if detention is higher than average, or if a missed appointment causes a stockout or chargeback, Carrier B can become the lower total-cost option quickly.

Worked Example 3: Shipment Design Change (Density and Equipment) That Lowers Cost

Scenario: You ship an LTL pallet that is bulky and light. By changing carton size and stacking pattern, you increase density and reduce the freight class.

Before: low density, higher class

• Pallet: 48×40×72 in → volume ≈ 80 cu ft
• Weight: 400 lb → density ≈ 5 lb/cu ft
• Rated class: assume Class 250
• Linehaul quote: $410

After: improved density, lower class

• Repack and stack to 48×40×60 in → volume ≈ 67 cu ft
• Same weight: 400 lb → density ≈ 6 lb/cu ft
• Rated class: assume Class 175
• Linehaul quote: $340
• Extra packaging cost: $8 (better corner boards/wrap)
• Extra labor: $6

Step-by-step comparison:

• Transportation savings: $410 - $340 = $70
• Added shipper cost: $8 + $6 = $14
• Net savings: $70 - $14 = $56 per shipment

Why this matters: the “rate” didn’t change; the shipment did. This is often a faster lever than carrier negotiations.

When the Lowest Freight Rate Is Not the Lowest Total Cost

Common situations where “cheap freight” becomes expensive

• High accessorial exposure: low base rate but frequent detention, liftgate, residential, or re-delivery charges.
• Damage and claims: inadequate packaging or rough handling increases replacement cost, reshipment cost, and customer dissatisfaction.
• Service failures: late deliveries trigger chargebacks, lost sales, expedited reships, or production downtime.
• Too many shipments: parceling everything may increase admin and packaging costs even if per-box rates look acceptable.
• Wrong equipment choice: saving on equipment can cause unload delays, site rejection, or additional handling fees.

Practical step-by-step: comparing options using total cost

1. List all cost components using the TTC model (linehaul, fuel, accessorials, packaging/handling, admin).
2. Estimate accessorial probability (e.g., detention likely at specific receivers; residential likely for certain ZIPs).
3. Convert to expected cost: Expected Accessorial = Probability × Fee.
4. Add service-impact costs if relevant (chargebacks, expedited rescue shipments, stockout risk).
5. Choose the option with the lowest total landed cost that still meets required service and risk tolerance.