Why Herbs Bruise (and Why It Matters)
Leafy herbs and tender greens are mostly water held in delicate cells. When you crush those cells instead of cleanly slicing them, you get bruising: darkened edges, a wet/mashed texture, and a harsher, sometimes bitter flavor from excess cell damage. Clean cuts keep herbs bright, aromatic, and visually fresh.
Bruising usually comes from three things: herbs that are wet, herbs that are over-handled, and blades that don’t slice cleanly (often dull, or used with too much downward force).
Herb Prep Fundamentals (Before Any Cutting)
1) Wash correctly
- Leafy herbs (basil, mint, cilantro, parsley): Swish gently in a bowl of cool water to loosen grit. Lift herbs out (don’t pour everything through a colander or the grit can settle back on leaves).
- Scallions: Rinse under cool water, paying attention to the top green leaves where sand can hide. If very gritty, split lengthwise and rinse between layers.
2) Dry thoroughly (this is non-negotiable for clean cuts)
- Salad spinner: Spin herbs in small batches so they dry evenly.
- Towel method: Lay herbs on a clean towel or paper towels, then gently roll and pat dry. Avoid wringing or squeezing.
Why drying matters: Wet leaves slide under the blade, clump together, and encourage crushing. Dry leaves stack and roll cleanly for chiffonade and chop more evenly.
3) Remove tough stems (selectively)
- Basil and mint: Pinch off leaves; discard thick stems. Small tender tips can be kept.
- Parsley and cilantro: Thick lower stems can be fibrous; remove them. Tender upper stems are flavorful and can be chopped with the leaves.
- Spinach: For mature spinach, strip away thick central ribs if they feel stringy; baby spinach usually needs no trimming.
Chiffonade: Thin Ribbons Without Bruising
Chiffonade is a technique for slicing leafy herbs and greens into fine ribbons. It works especially well for basil, mint, spinach, and similar leaves.
Best uses
- Basil: finishing pasta, pizza, caprese, soups
- Mint: salads, yogurt sauces, fruit, drinks
- Spinach: quick sautés, omelets, soups
Step-by-step chiffonade
- Dry the leaves completely. If they feel cool and damp, keep drying.
- Stack. Align 6–12 leaves (depending on size). Keep the stack neat; messy stacks lead to uneven ribbons.
- Roll. Roll the stack into a loose cigar. Don’t compress hard—compression increases bruising.
- Slice. Using smooth slicing strokes, cut crosswise into ribbons. Aim for minimal downward force; let the edge do the work.
- Fluff. Gently separate ribbons with fingertips. Avoid squeezing or over-tossing.
Thickness guide
| Ingredient | Typical ribbon width | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| Basil | 2–5 mm | Thinner for garnish; thicker for salads |
| Mint | 1–3 mm | Mint bruises easily; keep strokes light |
| Spinach | 5–10 mm | Often used as a “shred” rather than fine ribbons |
How to Avoid Crushing: Pressure, Motion, and Blade Condition
Why dull knives bruise herbs
A sharp edge separates cells with a clean slice. A dull edge tends to push and tear first, requiring extra force. That extra force compresses leaves against the board, rupturing more cells and leaving dark, wet-looking cut surfaces.
Continue in our app.
You can listen to the audiobook with the screen off, receive a free certificate for this course, and also have access to 5,000 other free online courses.
Or continue reading below...Download the app
Practical cues you’re crushing instead of slicing
- Leaves look darkened at the cut edge within minutes
- Cut pile looks wet or clumpy
- You feel the need to press down hard to get through the stack
Technique adjustments that reduce bruising
- Use lighter pressure: Think “glide” rather than “chop.”
- Use smooth strokes: A longer, smoother stroke reduces sawing and tearing.
- Cut smaller batches: Over-stacking forces you to press harder.
- Keep the board dry: Wipe moisture so leaves don’t skate.
- Cut close to serving time: Even clean cuts oxidize; minimize wait time for delicate herbs.
Parsley and Cilantro: Chopping Without Over-Processing
Parsley and cilantro are often chopped rather than chiffonaded because the leaf shape is irregular and the stems can be included. The goal is an even chop without turning herbs into a paste.
Step-by-step: clean herb chop
- Dry and de-stem. Remove thick lower stems; keep tender stems if you like.
- Gather into a loose mound. Don’t compress tightly.
- Make a few broad passes. Use controlled, smooth chopping strokes to reduce the pile.
- Rotate and regroup. Use your fingers to pull stray pieces back into a mound.
- Stop early. When pieces look even, stop. Over-chopping releases moisture and turns herbs darker and mushy.
Size targets (so you know when to stop)
- Garnish: 2–4 mm pieces
- Salsa/chimichurri-style use: 3–6 mm pieces (often better texture than ultra-fine)
Common mistakes
- Rocking rapidly for too long: creates heat and bruising; herbs become wet and compact.
- Chopping wet herbs: clumps and smears on the board.
- Cutting huge piles at once: forces extra pressure and uneven results.
Scallions (Green Onions): Rings and Bias Cuts
Scallions are sturdier than leafy herbs but still benefit from clean slicing for neat rings and attractive diagonal pieces.
Prep
- Trim the root end and any wilted green tips.
- If sandy, split lengthwise near the top and rinse between layers, then dry.
Rings (straight crosswise slices)
- Align scallions. If slicing multiple, line them up with the whites together.
- Slice crosswise. Use steady, even strokes to create rings.
- Choose thickness by use: thin (1–2 mm) for garnish; thicker (3–5 mm) for stir-fries.
Bias cuts (diagonal slices)
- Angle the scallion. Hold it so the knife cuts at roughly 30–45 degrees.
- Slice with consistent spacing. This creates longer, more elegant pieces that cook quickly and look intentional.
Tip: Bias cuts expose more surface area, which helps scallions soften faster in hot pans and spread flavor more quickly.
Storage Tips: Keep Herbs Fresh After Cutting (and Before)
Whole herbs (best for freshness)
- Parsley/cilantro: Treat like flowers. Trim stem ends, stand in a jar with a little water, cover loosely with a bag, refrigerate. Change water if cloudy.
- Mint: Similar jar method works well; keep away from very cold back-of-fridge spots to reduce blackening.
- Basil: Prefer cool room temperature if your kitchen isn’t hot; refrigerating can darken basil. Store stems in water like a bouquet and cover loosely.
Cut herbs (use soon, but store smart)
- Short-term (same day): Spread on a plate lined with a dry paper towel; cover lightly.
- Overnight: Store in an airtight container with a dry paper towel to absorb moisture. Avoid packing tightly.
Moisture control is the theme: too wet leads to slime; too dry leads to wilting. A paper towel buffer helps keep the balance.
Mini-Lab: Sharp vs. Dull Blade Herb Test
This quick comparison makes the effect of edge quality visible and memorable.
What you need
- One bunch of basil or mint (or both), washed and thoroughly dried
- Two knives: one very sharp, one noticeably dull (or a knife that hasn’t been maintained)
- Cutting board and paper towels
- Timer or clock
Procedure
- Divide the leaves. Make two equal piles with similar-sized leaves.
- Chiffonade pile A with the sharp knife. Use light pressure and smooth strokes.
- Chiffonade pile B with the dull knife. Use the same technique and try not to “compensate” with extra force (notice if you can’t).
- Observe immediately. Compare ribbon edges: clean and dry vs. ragged and wet.
- Wait 10 minutes. Compare color change and clumping.
- Smell test. Gently waft aroma from each pile; note if one smells greener/brighter and the other more harsh or “crushed.”
What to record
| Observation | Sharp knife | Dull knife |
|---|---|---|
| Edge appearance | Clean, defined ribbons | Ragged, torn edges |
| Moisture on board | Minimal | Noticeable wetness/smearing |
| Color after 10 minutes | Stays brighter | Darkening/bruising more visible |
| Texture | Light, fluffy | Clumpy, compressed |