Binding Energy, Mass Defect, and the Stability Landscape

From Mass Defect to Binding Energy (E = mc²)

When nucleons assemble into a nucleus, the mass of the bound nucleus is typically less than the sum of the masses of the same number of free protons and neutrons. This missing mass is the mass defect. The corresponding energy is the binding energy: the energy that would be required to separate the nucleus completely into free nucleons (or, equivalently, the energy released when the nucleus is formed from free nucleons).

Key definitions

• Mass defect: Δm = (mass of separated nucleons) − (mass of nucleus)
• Binding energy: BE = Δm c^2
• Common unit conversion: 1 u × c^2 = 931.494 MeV (often rounded to 931.5 MeV)

In practice, you will compute Δm using tabulated masses. The most convenient approach depends on which masses you have available.

Calculation Templates (Step-by-Step)

Template A: Using atomic masses (most common tables)

Atomic masses include the mass of the electrons. A very useful shortcut is that electron masses cancel if you use the mass of a hydrogen atom (^1H, i.e., a proton + one electron) for each proton.

Given: atomic mass of the nuclide M_atom(A,Z), atomic mass of hydrogen M(^1H), and neutron mass m_n.

1. Compute the mass of separated nucleons (in atomic-mass form): M_sep = Z·M(^1H) + (A−Z)·m_n
2. Compute mass defect: Δm = M_sep − M_atom(A,Z)
3. Convert to binding energy: BE(MeV) = Δm(u) × 931.494

Notes: This works because M_atom(A,Z) contains Z electrons, and Z·M(^1H) also contains Z electrons, so electron masses cancel without needing to subtract them explicitly.

Continue in our app.

• Listen to the audio with the screen off.
• Earn a certificate upon completion.
• Over 5000 courses for you to explore!

Or continue reading below...

Download the app

Template B: Using nuclear masses (if provided)

If you have nuclear mass M_nuc(A,Z) (no electrons included):

1. Compute separated nucleon mass: M_sep = Z·m_p + (A−Z)·m_n
2. Mass defect: Δm = M_sep − M_nuc(A,Z)
3. Binding energy: BE = Δm c^2 (convert u to MeV using 931.494 MeV/u)

Template C: Using mass excess (advanced tables)

Some tables provide mass excess Δ in MeV, defined by Δ = (M_atom − A·u) c^2. If you have mass excess values for the nucleus and for ^1H and the neutron, you can compute binding energy directly in MeV without converting u → MeV at the end. The idea is the same: compute the energy-equivalent of the mass defect by subtracting the nucleus from the separated nucleons, using consistent mass-excess data.

Binding Energy per Nucleon and Relative Stability

The total binding energy grows with the number of nucleons, so to compare how tightly bound different nuclei are, we use binding energy per nucleon:

BE/A (in MeV per nucleon) = (total binding energy BE in MeV) / A

• Higher BE/A generally means nucleons are more tightly bound and the nucleus is more stable against being pulled apart into free nucleons.
• Lower BE/A indicates a nucleus is less tightly bound; reactions that move to higher BE/A can release energy.

Practical comparison rule: If nucleus X has larger BE/A than nucleus Y, then (all else equal) X is more tightly bound per nucleon and is typically more stable with respect to processes that increase binding.

Worked mini-example (structure only)

Suppose you computed BE for two nuclei:

• Nucleus 1: BE = 92 MeV, A = 12 → BE/A = 7.67 MeV
• Nucleus 2: BE = 180 MeV, A = 20 → BE/A = 9.00 MeV

Nucleus 2 is more tightly bound per nucleon.

The Stability Landscape: The Valley of Stability

If you plot nuclides on a chart with neutron number N on one axis and proton number Z on the other, stable nuclides cluster in a band called the valley of stability. Nuclides far from this band tend to be unstable and transform toward the valley through radioactive decay processes that adjust the neutron-to-proton balance.

Neutron-to-proton ratio trends

A key descriptor is the ratio N/Z:

• Light nuclei: Stability is typically near N ≈ Z, so N/Z ≈ 1. Example: ^12C has N=6, Z=6.
• Heavier nuclei: Stability requires N > Z, so N/Z > 1, and the ratio gradually increases with Z. Example: ^208Pb has N=126, Z=82, so N/Z ≈ 1.54.

Why does the stable band bend toward neutron-rich values for heavy nuclei? As Z increases, the repulsive interaction associated with having many protons grows strongly. Adding neutrons increases attractive binding without increasing proton-related repulsion, helping large nuclei remain bound. The result is a stable region that shifts to higher N relative to Z as nuclei get heavier.

Interpreting “too many neutrons” or “too many protons”

• Neutron-rich (too large N/Z): the nucleus tends to move toward the valley by converting a neutron into a proton (a change that reduces N and increases Z).
• Proton-rich (too small N/Z): the nucleus tends to move toward the valley by converting a proton into a neutron (a change that increases N and reduces Z).

On an N vs Z chart, these moves shift the nuclide toward the stable band.

Why Energy Can Be Released by Splitting or Combining Nuclei

Nuclear reactions can release energy when the products have a higher total binding energy (or higher BE/A in a way that increases total binding) than the reactants. The energy released (the Q-value) is the increase in binding energy, which appears as kinetic energy of products and/or radiation.

Energy release by combining (fusion-like direction)

For many light nuclei, combining them into a heavier nucleus can increase BE/A. If the final nucleus is more tightly bound per nucleon, the total binding energy increases and energy is released.

Energy release by splitting (fission-like direction)

For very heavy nuclei, splitting into two medium-mass fragments can increase total binding energy because the fragments often have higher BE/A than the original heavy nucleus. The increase in binding energy becomes released energy.

Binding-energy viewpoint (reaction bookkeeping)

For a reaction Reactants → Products:

• Q ≈ [BE(products) − BE(reactants)]
• If Q > 0, energy is released (exothermic).
• If Q < 0, energy must be supplied (endothermic).

This is equivalent to doing the calculation with masses: Q = (m_initial − m_final) c^2, provided all masses are defined consistently (atomic with atomic, nuclear with nuclear).

Practice Problems

Problem 1: Compute binding energy from tabulated atomic masses

Data (atomic masses):

• M(^1H) = 1.007825 u
• m_n = 1.008665 u
• M_atom(^4He) = 4.002603 u

Task: Compute (a) mass defect Δm, (b) total binding energy BE in MeV, and (c) binding energy per nucleon BE/A for ^4He.

Template to fill:

Z = ___ , A = ___ , N = A − Z = ___  Mass of separated nucleons: M_sep = Z·M(^1H) + N·m_n = ___ u  Mass defect: Δm = M_sep − M_atom = ___ u  Binding energy: BE = Δm·931.494 = ___ MeV  Binding energy per nucleon: BE/A = ___ MeV/nucleon

Problem 2: Compare two nuclei for relative stability using BE/A

Data (atomic masses):

• M(^1H) = 1.007825 u
• m_n = 1.008665 u
• M_atom(^12C) = 12.000000 u
• M_atom(^16O) = 15.994915 u

Tasks:

• Compute BE and BE/A for ^12C and ^16O using Template A.
• Decide which nucleus is more tightly bound per nucleon.
• Explain, in one sentence, what a higher BE/A implies about stability against breakup into nucleons.

Workspace template:

Problem 3: Interpret why energy can be released by splitting or combining nuclei

Given:

• A light-nucleus reaction produces a product nucleus with larger BE/A than each reactant.
• A heavy-nucleus split produces two fragments whose combined binding energy is larger than the original nucleus’s binding energy.

Tasks:

1. For each case, state whether Q is positive or negative and why, using Q ≈ BE(products) − BE(reactants).
2. In each case, describe where the released energy comes from in mass terms (connect to Δm and E = mc^2).
3. On an N vs Z chart, describe qualitatively how moving toward the valley of stability relates to energy release (no calculations needed).