Understanding Risks, Second Opinions, and Pre-Op Questions in Neurosurgery

Why this chapter matters: informed consent as a practical skill

In neurosurgery, “informed consent” is not just a signature—it is a structured conversation that helps you understand what could happen, how likely it is, how bad it would be, and what alternatives exist. This chapter gives you a toolkit to interpret risk, seek second opinions effectively, and ask pre-op questions that lead to clear, usable answers.

1) How risk is presented (and how to interpret it)

Baseline risk: “What happens if we do nothing?”

Every procedure should be compared to a baseline: the expected course without surgery (or with non-surgical care). Baseline risk includes progression of symptoms, permanent neurologic injury, loss of function, or future emergency surgery. Ask for the baseline in concrete terms and a time frame.

• Example: “If I don’t have surgery, what is the chance my weakness becomes permanent in the next 3–6 months?”
• Example: “If we wait, what signs would mean I should go to the ER?”

Relative vs absolute risk: avoid being misled by percentages

Risk can be described as relative (a comparison) or absolute (the actual chance). Absolute risk is usually more useful for decisions.

• Relative risk example: “This approach reduces stroke risk by 50%.”
• Absolute risk example: “Stroke risk goes from 2% to 1%.”

Both statements can be true, but the absolute numbers help you judge whether the difference matters to you.

Likelihood vs severity: separate “how often” from “how bad”

Neurosurgical risks often include rare but severe outcomes and common but mild outcomes. A helpful way to think is a 2×2: common/rare and mild/severe.

Continue in our app.

• Listen to the audio with the screen off.
• Earn a certificate upon completion.
• Over 5000 courses for you to explore!

Or continue reading below...

Download the app

Uncertainty: when the honest answer is a range

Some risks can’t be pinned to a single number because they depend on anatomy, pathology details, and intraoperative findings. Good risk communication often uses ranges and explains what drives the uncertainty.

• Ask for ranges: “Is the risk closer to 1 in 100 or 1 in 10?”
• Ask what changes the risk: “What imaging features make it safer or riskier?”
• Ask about decision points: “If you see X during surgery, what are the options?”

A practical step-by-step to “translate” risk in clinic

1. Get the baseline: “What happens if we do nothing for 3 months? 1 year?”
2. Get absolute numbers when possible: “Out of 100 people like me, how many have this complication?”
3. Separate probability from impact: “If it happens, what would recovery look like?”
4. Ask what is preventable: “Which risks can we reduce with medication changes, timing, or technique?”
5. Confirm understanding: “Can I repeat back what I heard and you tell me if I got it right?”

2) Individualized factors that change risk and benefit

Two people can have the “same” diagnosis but very different risk profiles. Individualization is not a buzzword—it is the core of surgical decision-making.

Age and physiologic reserve

Age can correlate with slower recovery, higher anesthesia risk, and higher complication rates, but “physiologic age” matters too (mobility, nutrition, frailty, lung and heart function). Ask how your overall health changes the plan.

• “Do you consider me higher risk because of frailty or other factors?”
• “Would prehabilitation (walking, breathing exercises, nutrition) change my risk?”

Comorbidities: diabetes, sleep apnea, heart/lung disease, kidney disease

These conditions can influence infection risk, wound healing, blood pressure control, and anesthesia planning.

• Diabetes: “What glucose range do you want before and after surgery?”
• Sleep apnea: “Will I need special monitoring after anesthesia?”
• Heart disease: “Do I need cardiology clearance, and what would delay surgery?”

Medications: blood thinners, antiplatelets, and supplements

Blood thinners and antiplatelet drugs can reduce clot risk but increase bleeding risk. Stopping them can do the opposite. The plan must be individualized and coordinated with the prescribing clinician.

• Examples to explicitly mention: warfarin, apixaban/rivaroxaban, clopidogrel, aspirin, and certain supplements (e.g., fish oil, vitamin E, ginkgo) that may affect bleeding.
• Key questions: “When do I stop and restart?” “Do I need bridging?” “Who is responsible for the final plan?”

Step-by-step medication safety checklist (bring to pre-op):

1. Bring a complete list (dose, timing, last dose taken).
2. Ask which meds to continue the morning of surgery (blood pressure meds vary).
3. Ask which meds must be stopped and exactly when.
4. Ask what to do if you accidentally take a restricted medication.
5. Confirm the restart plan and who will write the orders.

Anatomy and technical complexity

Risk depends on where the target is, what structures are nearby, prior surgeries (scar tissue), and anatomical variants. Even with the same diagnosis, location can change the balance of benefit and risk.

• “What nearby nerves/vessels are the main concern in my case?”
• “How does prior surgery or hardware affect the plan?”
• “What is the backup plan if exposure is harder than expected?”

Urgency: elective vs time-sensitive vs emergent

Urgency changes the acceptable risk and how much optimization is possible. In elective situations, there is often time to correct anemia, improve nutrition, adjust medications, or obtain another opinion. In emergencies, the baseline risk of waiting may be the dominant factor.

• “Is this truly time-sensitive? What is the risk of waiting 2–4 weeks?”
• “What optimization steps would you want if we have time?”

3) Second opinions: when they help most and how to do them efficiently

A second opinion is not an insult; it is a quality-control step, especially when decisions are preference-sensitive (multiple reasonable options) or high stakes (rare but severe outcomes). The goal is to confirm diagnosis, clarify options, and test whether the plan matches your goals.

Situations where second opinions are especially helpful

• Elective spine surgery: when symptoms are bothersome but not rapidly progressive, when imaging findings don’t clearly match symptoms, or when the proposed surgery is extensive (multi-level fusion, revision surgery).
• Tumor strategy decisions: when choices include observation vs biopsy vs resection, or when the plan depends on balancing symptom relief, neurologic risk, and future treatments.
• Complex vascular decisions: when there are multiple approaches with different risk profiles and follow-up needs, or when the decision hinges on anatomy and long-term durability.

What a “good” second opinion should answer

• Do they agree with the diagnosis and the main pain/neurologic generator?
• Are there reasonable non-surgical or less invasive alternatives?
• Is the timing appropriate (now vs later)?
• Is the proposed approach the best match for your anatomy and goals?
• What are the key risks in your specific case?

How to share imaging and notes (step-by-step)

1. Request imaging files: Ask the radiology department for the actual images (DICOM) on a disc/USB or via electronic sharing—not just the radiology report.
2. Collect reports: MRI/CT/angiography reports, EMG reports if relevant, and any operative notes from prior surgeries.
3. Get clinic notes: The surgeon’s assessment and plan, including the proposed procedure name and levels/targets.
4. Prepare a one-page summary: symptoms timeline, what makes it better/worse, prior treatments tried, current meds, allergies, and your top 3 goals.
5. Ask for a focused question: “Do you agree surgery is indicated?” “Is there a different approach?” “Is observation reasonable?”

Tip: If two surgeons disagree, ask each to explain the trade-off they are prioritizing (durability, speed of recovery, neurologic risk, re-operation risk). Disagreement often reflects different weighting of values, not incompetence.

4) A structured pre-op question list (use this like a script)

Bring this list to your visit and write down answers. If possible, have a family member or friend take notes. Ask for plain-language explanations first, then details.

A) Goals of surgery (define success)

• “What is the primary goal: pain relief, preventing worsening, improving strength/balance, reducing seizures, protecting function?”
• “How will we measure success at 2 weeks, 6 weeks, 3 months, and 1 year?”
• “What symptoms are unlikely to improve even if surgery goes perfectly?”

B) Alternatives (including doing nothing)

• “What are the reasonable alternatives right now?”
• “What is the best non-surgical plan, and how long should we try it before reassessing?”
• “What happens if I do nothing for the next 1–3 months? 6–12 months?”

C) Expected benefit timeline (when improvement happens)

• “Which improvements are immediate vs gradual?”
• “When would you say the surgery ‘worked’—and when would you worry it didn’t?”
• “What is the typical recovery curve for someone like me?”

D) Risks and trade-offs (personalized)

• “What are the top 3 risks in my specific case?”
• “Which risks are rare but severe?”
• “What is the chance I need another procedure later?”
• “What can we do before surgery to reduce risk?”

E) Surgeon and team experience (ask without awkwardness)

• “How often do you perform this exact procedure?”
• “What are your typical outcomes and complication rates for cases like mine?”
• “Who will be involved (assistant surgeon, trainees), and what will each person do?”

F) Anesthesia and perioperative plan

• “What type of anesthesia will I have, and why is it best for this case?”
• “How will pain be controlled after surgery (multimodal plan)?”
• “Do I need special monitoring afterward (ICU vs regular floor)?”
• “What is the plan for nausea prevention and bowel regimen?”

G) Practical logistics: hospital stay, restrictions, and return to life

• “How long is the expected hospital stay?”
• “What restrictions will I have (lifting, bending, driving, work, sexual activity), and for how long?”
• “When can I shower? What wound care is required?”
• “When can I restart my usual medications, including blood thinners?”

H) Warning signs and what to do (clear thresholds)

• “What symptoms after surgery are normal, and what is not normal?”
• “What are the red flags that mean call the office today vs go to the ER?”
• “Who do I contact after hours, and what is the fastest route to reach the team?”

I) Follow-up schedule and contingency plans

• “When is my first follow-up, and what will be assessed?”
• “Will I need repeat imaging? If yes, when and why?”
• “If I’m not improving on schedule, what is the stepwise plan?”

One-page pre-op worksheet (copy/paste)

My top goals (rank 1–3): 1) ____ 2) ____ 3) ____
Biggest fears/risks I want to avoid: ____
Baseline if no surgery (time frame): ____
Proposed procedure (name/levels/target): ____
Expected benefits: ____
Benefits unlikely: ____
Top 3 personalized risks: ____
Plan to reduce risk (med changes, optimization): ____
Hospital stay estimate: ____
Restrictions + duration: ____
Red flags + action plan: ____
Follow-up schedule: ____

5) Documenting decisions and aligning with patient values

Many neurosurgical choices are not “right vs wrong” but “which trade-off fits you.” Two patients can reasonably choose different paths with the same clinical facts.

Clarify your values: pain relief vs function vs risk tolerance

Use a simple values map to make your priorities explicit.

• Pain relief priority: “I can accept a longer recovery or higher re-operation risk if pain relief is more likely.”
• Function priority: “I care most about preserving strength/balance/hand function, even if pain relief is incomplete.”
• Risk-avoidant priority: “I prefer the option with the lowest chance of severe complications, even if improvement is smaller or slower.”
• Durability priority: “I prefer a plan that reduces the chance of needing another procedure later, even if the initial procedure is bigger.”

Turn values into a decision framework (step-by-step)

1. List options: surgery option A, surgery option B, non-surgical plan, observation.
2. For each option, write: expected benefit, time to benefit, key risks (common and rare), and what failure looks like.
3. Assign weights: rank what matters most (pain, function, independence, speed of recovery, avoiding catastrophic risk, avoiding repeat procedures).
4. Identify deal-breakers: outcomes you would find unacceptable (e.g., loss of independence, prolonged rehab, certain neurologic deficits).
5. Ask the surgeon to reflect back: “Given my priorities, which option best matches—and why?”

Document the decision so everyone stays aligned

Documentation reduces misunderstandings and helps continuity of care.

• Ask for a written plan: procedure name, goals, key risks discussed, and what would change the plan.
• Use the visit summary: many systems provide an after-visit summary—review it for accuracy.
• Send a confirmation message: a short portal message can clarify: “My understanding is X; please confirm.”
• Bring your worksheet on surgery day: it helps you and your support person verify medication instructions, restrictions, and follow-up.