Troubleshooting Tile Installation: Lippage, Hollow Spots, and Cracked Grout

Diagnosis-First Troubleshooting: Symptom-to-Cause Mapping

Tile problems are easiest to fix when you identify whether the root cause is the substrate (what the tile is bonded to) or the setting process (how the tile was installed). Use the symptoms below to narrow the cause before you remove anything.

Quick triage: what you can observe without demolition

• Is the problem isolated or widespread? One or two tiles usually points to setting technique or contamination. A repeating pattern across a large area often points to substrate flatness, layout, or movement.
• Does it change with temperature or moisture? Problems that worsen seasonally can indicate movement, moisture, or expansion constraints.
• Does it sound hollow? Hollow sound can indicate poor bond or voids, but it can also occur over certain substrates; confirm with additional checks.
• Where is it located? Near doorways, transitions, edges, and wet areas often indicates movement, deflection, or moisture-related issues.

Symptom-to-cause table (beginner-friendly)

Two simple tests to separate “flatness” from “technique”

• Straightedge sweep: Place a long straightedge across several tiles in different directions. If you see consistent rocking or gaps that span multiple tiles, suspect substrate flatness or a systematic thickness issue. If only one tile is high/low, suspect technique or a warped tile.
• Pattern check: If lippage aligns with a row, seam line, or a repeating ridge, suspect substrate transitions, seams, or a layout/sequence issue. If it’s random, suspect inconsistent mortar, inadequate collapse of ridges, or tile warpage.

Lippage: Causes, Prevention, and When Replacement Is Required

Lippage is when one tile edge sits higher than the neighboring tile. It’s both a comfort/safety issue and a visual defect. Some lippage can be within acceptable tolerance depending on tile type and size, but beginners should focus on eliminating obvious “toe-catch” edges and noticeable shadow lines.

Common causes (what’s really happening)

• Warped (cupped/bowed) tile: Large-format tiles can have slight curvature. If you force corners down, the middle may rise (or vice versa), creating lippage at edges.
• Insufficient leveling during setting: Tiles placed without checking adjacent edges can “freeze” in place once mortar starts to firm up.
• Poor layout choices for warped tile: Certain patterns (like offset patterns) can exaggerate warpage-related lippage by placing high points next to low points.
• Inconsistent mortar thickness: Too much mortar under one tile or too little under the next creates height differences.
• Substrate flatness problems: A hump or dip forces tiles to follow the surface, especially with rigid tile.

Prevention checklist (during installation)

• Dry-check tile warpage: Place two tiles face-to-face and see if they rock; check with a straightedge across the tile. If noticeably warped, plan your layout and lippage-control approach accordingly.
• Control mortar thickness: Use consistent trowel angle and pressure; avoid “spot bonding” that creates high points.
• Work in small areas: This gives time to adjust tile height before mortar firms up.
• Continuously verify with a straightedge: Don’t rely on your eyes alone; check every few tiles.

Repair decision: grind, reset, or replace?

Choose the least invasive fix that actually solves the cause.

• Minor lippage on porcelain with a sharp edge: Sometimes a professional can hone edges, but beginners risk damaging glaze and creating a permanent dull spot. In most DIY cases, do not grind glazed edges.
• Lippage caused by a single high tile: If the tile is still fresh (mortar not cured), lift and reset immediately. If cured, removal and reset is usually the correct repair.
• Widespread lippage across an area: This often indicates substrate flatness or systematic technique issues. Replacing one tile won’t fix the overall plane; plan for a larger reset after identifying the underlying cause.

Step-by-step: replacing a lipped tile (cured installation)

1. Protect surrounding tile: Apply painter’s tape around the tile edges to reduce chipping risk.
2. Remove grout around the tile: Use a grout removal tool to clear the joint to full depth around the tile. This isolates the tile and reduces edge chipping.
3. Break the tile safely: Tap near the center to fracture it, then work outward. Avoid prying against neighboring tile edges.
4. Remove mortar from the substrate: Scrape/abrade until the surface is clean and flat enough for reset. Any ridges left behind can recreate lippage.
5. Dry-fit and check height: Place the replacement tile without mortar and check it against neighbors with a straightedge.
6. Reset the tile: Apply fresh mortar, set the tile, and adjust height so edges align. Recheck with a straightedge in multiple directions.
7. Allow cure, then regrout: Match grout type and color; protect from traffic until cured.

Hollow Spots and Debonding: Why Tiles Sound Hollow and How to Fix Them

A hollow spot is an area under a tile where mortar coverage is missing or not bonded. It may sound different when tapped and can lead to cracked grout, loose tiles, or eventual breakage.

Common causes

• Coverage failures: Mortar ridges not collapsed, insufficient mortar, or poor contact between tile and mortar.
• Skinned mortar: Mortar left exposed too long forms a dry film; the tile bonds poorly even if it looks set.
• Contamination: Dust, drywall compound, overspray, sealer residue, or dirty tile backs can prevent bonding.
• Movement or moisture stress: Even decent coverage can fail if the assembly moves or stays wet.

How to confirm a true bond problem (not just “different sound”)

• Tap test mapping: Tap with a coin or the handle of a screwdriver and mark hollow-sounding zones with painter’s tape. A small hollow area may be acceptable in some situations, but large or expanding areas are a red flag.
• Check grout lines around the tile: Cracked grout bordering the tile can indicate movement or loss of support.
• Check for vertical movement: Step on the tile (carefully). Any “click” or movement suggests debonding and requires repair.

Repair approach: remove and reset (most reliable)

Injection repairs are inconsistent for beginners and may not restore full support. The dependable fix is to remove the affected tile(s), correct the cause, and reset.

Continue in our app.

You can listen to the audiobook with the screen off, receive a free certificate for this course, and also have access to 5,000 other free online courses.

Or continue reading below...

Download the app

Step-by-step: removing and resetting a hollow/loose tile

1. Isolate the tile: Remove grout around it to full depth to prevent chipping neighboring tiles.
2. Lift the tile: If it’s already loose, it may come up with minimal force. If bonded in spots, break it from the center outward.
3. Inspect the back of the tile and substrate: Look for clues: powdery mortar (poor cure), clean tile back (no transfer), dusty substrate, or a “skin” layer.
4. Correct the cause:
   • If you see dust/contamination: clean thoroughly and let dry.
   • If mortar skinned: work in smaller sections and set tile sooner.
   • If coverage was low: adjust technique so the tile is fully supported.
5. Prepare surfaces: Remove old mortar ridges; ensure the reset area is flat enough to avoid lippage.
6. Reset with fresh mortar: Set the tile and verify it is fully supported by pressing and moving it slightly to collapse ridges (without shifting it out of alignment).
7. Recheck plane and joints: Use a straightedge to confirm the tile sits flush with neighbors.
8. Cure and regrout: Keep traffic off until cured; then grout and clean carefully.

Cracked Grout: Missing Movement Joints, Flex, and Premature Traffic

Cracked grout is a symptom, not the problem itself. The key is to determine whether the crack is from movement (the assembly is shifting) or from grout issues (weak, shrinking, or poorly packed grout).

Common causes and how they present

• Movement joints missing or bridged: Cracks often appear at perimeters, where tile meets another material, or at changes of plane (wall-to-floor, inside corners). If grout is used where a flexible joint should be, it commonly cracks.
• Structural flex: Cracks may run in lines that mirror subfloor seams or framing direction. You may also notice tile or grout “crunching” under load.
• Premature traffic or vibration: Cracks can appear soon after installation, sometimes with slightly powdery grout at the surface.
• Insufficient joint fill: Shallow grout (not packed full depth) can crack or crumble, especially at edges.

Remediation: regrout vs. caulk (flexible sealant) joints

Use this rule: If the joint is intended to move, do not grout it. Use a flexible sealant in those locations. If the joint is between tiles on the same plane and not a movement location, regrouting is usually appropriate.

• Regrout when: cracks are in field joints, the tile is solid (no movement), and the crack is due to poor packing, shrinkage, or localized damage.
• Use flexible sealant when: cracks occur at changes of plane, perimeters, transitions, or anywhere movement is expected.

Step-by-step: repairing cracked grout in field joints (regrout)

1. Remove the cracked grout: Remove to a consistent depth so new grout has enough thickness to bond. Avoid chipping tile edges.
2. Vacuum and clean: Dust left in the joint weakens the repair. Wipe lightly with a damp sponge and let dry as needed.
3. Reapply grout: Pack firmly so the joint is full and dense, not just “topped off.”
4. Tool and clean: Shape joints consistently and clean residue without washing grout out of the joint.
5. Protect from traffic: Keep the area undisturbed for the required cure time to prevent re-cracking.

Step-by-step: converting a cracked corner/perimeter joint to flexible sealant

1. Remove grout from the joint completely: The joint must be free of rigid grout to move properly.
2. Clean and dry: Remove dust and residue; ensure the joint is dry so the sealant adheres.
3. Mask edges: Tape both sides for a clean line.
4. Apply sealant: Run a continuous bead, then tool it to a smooth concave shape.
5. Remove tape and protect: Pull tape immediately after tooling; keep the joint clean and dry while it cures.

Efflorescence and Discoloration: Moisture Sources and Cleaning Methods

Efflorescence is a white, powdery deposit that forms when moisture moves through cement-based materials and carries salts to the surface. Discoloration can also come from uneven drying, lingering moisture, or cleaning residue.

Identify what you’re seeing

• Efflorescence: White powder or crystals; often reappears after cleaning if moisture is still present.
• Haze/residue: A film that smears when wet; may feel slightly soapy or sticky.
• Blotchy grout: Uneven color that correlates with damp areas, slow drying, or inconsistent cleanup water.

Find and address moisture sources (before repeated cleaning)

• Wet-area leaks or chronic dampness: Plumbing, shower details, or water intrusion can keep materials wet.
• Moisture from below: On slabs or basements, moisture vapor can drive salts upward.
• Slow drying conditions: Poor ventilation, low temperature, or high humidity can prolong curing and discoloration.

Beginner-safe cleaning sequence (least aggressive first)

1. Dry brush and vacuum: For powdery deposits, remove loose material first.
2. Clean with pH-neutral cleaner: Use a nylon brush and clean water rinse. This addresses many residues without attacking grout.
3. For persistent efflorescence: Use a cleaner specifically labeled for efflorescence/grout haze and follow directions exactly. Test in an inconspicuous area first and rinse thoroughly.
4. Let it dry fully and reassess: If it returns, focus on moisture control rather than stronger chemicals.

Preventive QA Routine: Catch Problems Early During Prep, Setting, and Grouting

Most tile failures start small. A simple quality-assurance routine helps you spot issues while they’re still easy to correct.

Prep checkpoints (before setting)

• Flatness verification: Check multiple directions with a straightedge and mark highs/lows. If you can predict where lippage will happen, you can prevent it.
• Cleanliness check: Vacuum and wipe surfaces; remove dust and debris that can cause debonding.
• Dry layout sanity check: Confirm cuts and transitions so you’re not forced into rushed adjustments that create lippage.

Setting checkpoints (while tile is going in)

• Time control: Only spread as much mortar as you can cover while it’s still fresh. If you touch mortar and it doesn’t transfer to your finger, treat it as suspect.
• Plane control: Every few tiles, use a straightedge across multiple tiles; correct immediately rather than “fixing later.”
• Support check: Watch for tiles that sink or sit high compared to neighbors; address mortar thickness and contact right away.
• Edge cleanliness: Keep joints clear enough for full-depth grout; packed thinset in joints can lead to shallow grout and cracking.

Grouting checkpoints (before and after)

• Joint depth and cleanliness: Ensure joints are not blocked and are consistent so grout has uniform thickness.
• Movement joint protection: Keep movement joints free of grout so they can be sealed properly.
• Early crack watch: If cracks appear quickly, stop and diagnose movement or premature traffic rather than repeatedly patching.
• Moisture and cure control: Maintain stable conditions and keep traffic off until cured to prevent cracking and discoloration.