Payroll Controls and Common Errors: Preventing Misstatements and Cash Surprises

1) Common Payroll Errors That Create Misstatements and Cash Surprises

Payroll errors tend to show up in two places: (a) employees get paid incorrectly (trust and morale issue), and (b) the general ledger (GL) and cash don’t match expectations (financial reporting and cash management issue). The goal of payroll controls is to prevent these errors before money leaves the bank and to detect them quickly when they slip through.

Incorrect hours or rates

• What it looks like: overtime not applied, wrong hourly rate after a raise, missed unpaid time off, or incorrect shift differential.
• Why it matters in accounting: wage expense is wrong and cash paid may not match what was earned for the period.
• Common root causes: manual time edits without approval, outdated pay rate tables, late time submissions, or unclear rules for overtime eligibility.

Duplicate payments

• What it looks like: the same employee is paid twice for the same period, a terminated employee is paid again, or a manual check is issued and the regular run still pays them.
• Why it matters in accounting: cash is overstated outflow; wage expense may be overstated unless recovered; liabilities may be misstated if the duplicate included withholdings.
• Common root causes: off-cycle payments not flagged, reprocessing after a failed run, or poor coordination between HR/payroll/accounting.

Misclassified deductions (wrong bucket)

• What it looks like: a deduction is treated as a tax withholding when it’s actually a benefit premium, or a benefit is treated as employer-paid when it’s employee-paid (or vice versa).
• Why it matters in accounting: the wrong liability account is credited (e.g., “Payroll Taxes Payable” instead of “Benefits Payable”), causing remittance confusion and reconciliation breaks.
• Common root causes: new deduction codes set up incorrectly, changes in benefit plans not communicated, or inconsistent naming conventions for deduction types.

Incorrect liability postings

• What it looks like: payroll taxes withheld are posted to an expense account, employer taxes are posted to a liability, or liabilities are posted to the wrong period.
• Why it matters in accounting: balance sheet payroll liabilities won’t agree to what is actually owed; expenses may be misstated by period.
• Common root causes: mapping errors from payroll reports to GL accounts, manual journal entries, or using last period’s template without updating amounts.

Missed accruals

• What it looks like: wages earned near period-end are not accrued, or the accrual is not reversed/updated properly in the next period.
• Why it matters in accounting: wage expense and wage liabilities are understated in one period and overstated in the next, creating “surprise” swings.
• Common root causes: unclear cutoff procedures, late time approvals, or no ownership for the accrual calculation and review.

2) Key Controls to Reduce Payroll Errors (Accounting-Focused, Non-Technical)

Controls work best when they are simple, repeatable, and tied to a specific risk. Below are practical controls you can implement without relying on any specific software.

Segregation of duties (SoD)

Purpose: reduce the risk of unauthorized pay changes and concealment of errors or fraud.

Practical setup (small to mid-size team):

• Time entry/collection: supervisors or department admins collect and submit time.
• Pay rate and employee master changes: HR (or a separate admin) initiates changes with documentation.
• Payroll processing: payroll clerk prepares the run and payroll register.
• Payroll review and release: accounting/finance reviews totals and approves release of funds.
• Bank reconciliation: someone not running payroll performs (or reviews) the bank reconciliation.

If you have limited staff: keep at least one independent review step (e.g., controller reviews the payroll register and the bank debit) and require written approvals for changes.

Continue in our app.

You can listen to the audiobook with the screen off, receive a free certificate for this course, and also have access to 5,000 other free online courses.

Or continue reading below...

Download the app

Approval workflows for time and pay changes

Purpose: prevent incorrect hours/rates and reduce disputes.

Step-by-step control for time approval:

1. Cutoff schedule: publish a time submission deadline (e.g., noon the day after period end).
2. Supervisor review: supervisor confirms hours, overtime, and paid/unpaid leave.
3. Exception log: any manual edits require a short note (who, what, why) and supervisor sign-off.
4. Payroll pre-check: payroll compares submitted hours to prior period for large swings.

Step-by-step control for pay rate changes:

1. Documentation required: approved compensation change form (or written authorization).
2. Effective date check: confirm the date aligns with the pay period cutoff.
3. Dual review: one person enters the change; another verifies against the authorization.
4. Change report review: reviewer signs off on a list of all rate/master changes for the period.

Payroll register review (before cash is released)

Purpose: catch duplicates, unusual net pay, and mapping issues before money leaves the bank.

What to review (quick but effective):

• Headcount reasonableness: compare number of paid employees to active roster; investigate new/terminated employees paid.
• Top earners / outliers: scan the highest gross and highest net payments; confirm legitimacy.
• Zero or negative net pay: identify unusual cases and confirm deductions/adjustments.
• Manual checks/off-cycle items: ensure they are not duplicated in the regular run.
• Department totals: compare wage totals by department to budget or prior period.

Reconciliation of payroll liabilities to remittance confirmations

Purpose: ensure what the GL says you owe matches what you actually remitted (or will remit). This prevents “we thought it was paid” surprises and helps catch misclassified deductions.

Step-by-step monthly (or each pay period if feasible):

1. Start with the GL payroll liability accounts: taxes payable, benefits payable, wage payable (if applicable), and any garnishment/other payables.
2. Add current period payroll postings: the amounts credited to each liability from payroll.
3. Subtract remittances: match each payment to a remittance confirmation (date, amount, type).
4. Investigate differences: timing (in transit) vs. true errors (wrong account, wrong amount, missed remittance).
5. Document open items: keep a short list of what remains payable and when it will be remitted.

Periodic trend checks (simple analytics without being “technical”)

Purpose: detect issues that single-transaction reviews may miss.

Examples of trend checks to run monthly or quarterly:

• Payroll expense trend: compare wages and employer costs to prior months and to revenue/headcount changes.
• Overtime trend: overtime hours or dollars by department; spikes often indicate time entry errors or staffing issues.
• Average pay per employee: total gross pay divided by paid headcount; large jumps can signal rate errors or duplicate payments.
• Deductions as a % of gross: sudden shifts can indicate deduction setup or classification problems.
• Liability balance trend: payroll tax payable and benefits payable should not drift upward without a known timing reason.

3) Simple Reconciliation Checklist (Use Every Pay Period)

This checklist is designed to be short enough to actually use. Treat it as a sign-off package: attach the payroll register, the cash proof, and the liability rollforward.

A. Gross-to-net tie-out

Goal: confirm the payroll register internally “adds up.”

• Step 1: Obtain the payroll register totals for the pay run.
• Step 2: Verify the basic equation: Gross Pay − Employee Deductions/Withholdings = Net Pay
• Step 3: Agree totals to the summary by category (gross, each major deduction type, net).
• Step 4: Spot-check a few employees (new hire, hourly with overtime, salaried) for reasonableness.

Example tie-out (totals): Gross Pay                  120,000 Employee deductions/withholdings  35,000 Net Pay                     85,000 Check: 120,000 − 35,000 = 85,000 ✔

B. Cash-to-payroll register match

Goal: confirm the cash leaving the bank matches what was approved.

• Step 1: Identify the expected cash outflows from the payroll register (net pay, plus any separate employer payments if applicable).
• Step 2: Match to bank debits (or pending debits) by date and amount.
• Step 3: Investigate differences: duplicate debit, reversal, split batches, or timing.

C. Liability rollforward (payroll liabilities)

Goal: ensure liabilities move logically from period to period and agree to remittances.

Rollforward format:

Beginning liability balance + Current period additions (from payroll) − Remittances/payments = Ending liability balance

Example (Payroll Taxes Payable):

Beginning balance (taxes payable)      18,000 + Additions this pay period          12,500 − Remittances made                    10,000 = Ending balance                      20,500

What to look for:

• Ending balance too high: possible missed remittance, misposting to wrong account, or duplicate liability posting.
• Ending balance negative: remittance posted twice, remittance coded to wrong liability, or payroll posting missing.
• Doesn’t match remittance confirmations: amounts may be classified incorrectly (tax vs. benefit vs. garnishment).

4) Scenario-Based Exercise: Spot the Likely Misstated Account

For each scenario, identify the most likely misstated account (or account category). Choose one primary account to investigate first.

Exercise scenarios

1. Scenario A (incorrect rate): An employee received a raise effective this pay period, but payroll used the old rate. Net pay is lower than expected, and the employee complains.

   • Likely misstated account: Wage expense (understated) and potentially Wages payable if you later correct via an additional payment.

2. Scenario B (duplicate payment): A manual check was issued to fix a prior error. The next regular payroll run also paid the same employee for the same hours. The bank shows two debits.

   • Likely misstated account: Cash (overstated outflow) and Wage expense (overstated) unless the duplicate is recorded as a receivable from the employee or recovered.

3. Scenario C (misclassified deductions): Employee health insurance deductions were accidentally posted to “Payroll Taxes Payable.” Tax remittances now appear short, and the benefits payable account looks unusually low.

   • Likely misstated account: Payroll taxes payable (overstated) and Benefits payable (understated).

4. Scenario D (incorrect liability posting): The payroll entry credited “Wages expense” instead of “Payroll taxes payable” for employee tax withholdings. The income statement looks unusually low for payroll tax expense, and liabilities don’t reconcile to remittance confirmations.

   • Likely misstated account: Payroll taxes payable (understated) and Wage expense (misstated due to incorrect credit).

5. Scenario E (missed accrual): Month-end payroll cutoff was missed. The last two days of the month were worked but not included in the month’s payroll accrual. Next month’s wage expense looks high.

   • Likely misstated account: Wage expense (understated in the current month, overstated next month) and Accrued wages / wages payable (understated at month-end).

Quick self-check: what evidence would you pull?

• Payroll register: confirm amounts, employee-level detail, and any off-cycle items.
• Change/exception log: verify approvals for rate changes and manual edits.
• Bank activity: confirm number and amount of debits match the approved payroll totals.
• Liability rollforward + remittance confirmations: validate what was withheld/owed vs. what was paid.
• Trend checks: look for spikes in overtime, average pay, or liability balances.