Evaluating Substrates for Tile: Floors and Walls

1) Substrate requirements: clean, sound, flat, dry, and properly supported

A tile installation is only as reliable as the surface beneath it. Tile and grout are rigid; they tolerate very little movement, unevenness, or weak bonding surfaces. Before you think about layout or mortar choice, verify five fundamentals.

• Clean: Free of dust, drywall mud, grease, wax, soap residue, and loose paint. Anything that prevents mortar from mechanically bonding is a risk.
• Sound: The substrate must be structurally intact: no crumbling concrete, delaminated plywood, loose plaster keys, hollow-sounding areas, or loose existing tile.
• Flat: Flatness controls lippage (tile edges sticking up) and coverage. “Flat” is not the same as “level.” A floor can be out of level and still be flat enough to tile.
• Dry: Excess moisture can weaken some substrates, promote mold behind finishes, and interfere with bonding. Dryness requirements vary by substrate and setting materials, but “visibly damp” is never acceptable.
• Properly supported: Floors must resist bending (deflection). Walls must resist flexing and be adequately fastened. Movement is the enemy of tile.

Practical quick screen: If you can scrape off the surface with a putty knife, if it flexes when you press hard, or if it sheds dust continuously, it is not tile-ready.

2) Floor structure basics: deflection and why movement cracks grout/tile

Deflection is how much a floor system bends under load. Even small bending can crack grout lines, loosen tiles, or cause “tenting” (tiles lifting). Tile assemblies work best when the structure behaves like a stiff platform.

Two types of movement matter

• Joist deflection: Bending of the framing members (joists) between supports (beams/walls). This is influenced by joist size, spacing, species/grade, and span.
• Subfloor deflection (between-joist deflection): Bending of the sheathing (plywood/OSB) between joists. This is influenced by panel thickness, fastening, and whether there is a second layer or an underlayment.

Why cracks happen: Tile and grout are strong in compression but weak in tension and shear. When the floor bends, the tile layer is forced to stretch on top and compress below. Grout lines often crack first because they are thinner and more brittle; tiles can crack next, especially over seams, high spots, or voids in mortar coverage.

Field check you can do before calculations

• Walk the floor. If you feel bounce, hear squeaks, or see items on a table visibly shake, assume the floor needs structural attention.
• Look for long cracks in existing finishes aligned with joists or seams; these can indicate movement.
• Check from below (if accessible): identify joist size, spacing, and span; note any notches, holes, or damage.

Important: A floor can feel “solid” but still be marginal for tile, especially with large-format tile. When in doubt, stiffen the system (additional plywood layer, proper underlayment, or framing improvements) rather than hoping mortar will compensate.

Continue in our app.

You can listen to the audiobook with the screen off, receive a free certificate for this course, and also have access to 5,000 other free online courses.

Or continue reading below...

Download the app

3) Identifying common substrates and what is acceptable where

Not every surface that looks smooth is suitable for tile. Identify what you have, then decide whether it is acceptable for the location (dry interior, wet area, floor vs wall) and what preparation is required.

Location-based acceptability (quick guidance)

• Wet areas (showers, tub surrounds, steam-prone zones): Substrate must be compatible with a waterproofing system. Regular drywall and unstable plaster are common “no” surfaces unless a specific approved system is used.
• Floors: Wood-based substrates require attention to stiffness and underlayment. Concrete requires moisture/contamination checks and crack evaluation.
• Walls: Flatness and plumb matter more for appearance; fastening and rigidity matter to prevent flexing.

4) Flatness and plumb checks: straightedges/levels, tolerance targets, and measurement

Flatness is about how much the surface varies from a plane. Plumb is vertical alignment (walls). Level is horizontal alignment (floors). Tile cares most about flatness; walls also need to be reasonably plumb to avoid tapered cuts and awkward transitions.

Typical tolerance targets (field-friendly)

• For standard tile: Aim for no more than about 1/4 in. variation in 10 ft and 1/16 in. in 1 ft.
• For large-format tile (one side ≥ 15 in.): Aim tighter: about 1/8 in. in 10 ft and 1/16 in. in 2 ft.

These targets are commonly used in tile work because large tiles bridge over dips and rock on humps, making lippage hard to control.

Step-by-step: checking floor flatness

1. Choose a straightedge: Use a long straightedge (6–10 ft) or a very straight level. The longer it is, the more meaningful the reading.
2. Scan multiple directions: Check along the length, width, and diagonals. Dips often hide when you only check one direction.
3. Mark highs and lows: Use a pencil or tape to mark ridges (high spots) and depressions (low spots). Mark the depth if you can.
4. Measure gaps: Where you see daylight under the straightedge, measure the gap with feeler gauges, stacked shims, or a ruler. Record the worst areas.
5. Check seams and patches: Pay special attention to plywood panel edges, concrete control joints, and patch transitions.

Step-by-step: checking wall plumb and flatness

1. Plumb check: Hold a 4–6 ft level vertically in several locations. Note whether the wall leans in/out.
2. Flatness check: Use a straightedge horizontally and diagonally across studs/plaster. Mark bellies (high) and hollows (low).
3. Corner check: Check inside corners for straightness; bowed corners cause gaps and uneven grout lines.
4. Plan for tile transitions: If one wall is out of plumb, decide whether to correct the wall or adjust layout/cuts to hide it.

Interpreting results: If the surface is mostly within tolerance with a few isolated issues, it “needs prep.” If the entire plane is wavy or severely out, it may be faster and better to rebuild/overlay rather than patch endlessly.

5) Moisture and contamination checks (paint, sealers, oils, curing compounds) and remediation

Bond failures often trace back to invisible problems: moisture moving through concrete, or a film on the surface that prevents mortar from grabbing.

Moisture checks

• Concrete slabs: Look for dark areas, efflorescence (white salts), or persistent damp smell. A simple field screen is a taped plastic sheet test: tape down a square of clear plastic and leave it 24 hours; condensation or darkening suggests moisture vapor. For critical installs, use a proper moisture test method specified by the setting-material manufacturer.
• Wood substrates: Look for swelling, staining, mold, or soft spots. Investigate plumbing leaks and seasonal humidity issues. Wood that is actively wet or repeatedly damp is not tile-ready.

Contamination checks

• Painted surfaces: Paint can be a bond breaker, especially glossy or poorly adhered paint. Test adhesion by scoring a small grid with a utility knife and applying tape; if paint pulls off easily, it must be removed.
• Sealers/waxes/soap films: Common on existing tile and some concrete. Water beading is a clue. Mortar generally will not bond reliably to waxy or sealed surfaces without mechanical abrasion and cleaning.
• Oils/grease: Often near kitchens, garages, or workshops. If water doesn’t wet the surface evenly, suspect oil contamination.
• Curing compounds on concrete: Some slabs have curing membranes that inhibit bonding. They may be invisible; a water-drop test and abrasion test can help identify them.

Remediation options (choose based on what you find)

• Mechanical removal (preferred for bond breakers): Grinding, sanding, or scarifying to expose clean, sound material. This is often the most reliable fix for sealers, curing compounds, and glossy surfaces.
• Cleaning/degreasing: Use an appropriate degreaser and thorough rinsing for oils/grease. Cleaning alone is rarely enough if contamination has soaked in; mechanical removal may still be required.
• Overlay/underlayment approach: If direct bonding is questionable, install an appropriate tile underlayment or membrane over a properly prepared base (for example, over wood subfloors or over existing tile when allowed). This does not excuse loose or unstable substrates.
• Moisture management: For slabs with moisture vapor issues, use a system rated for the measured conditions (often a manufacturer-approved moisture mitigation or membrane). Do not “trap” active water problems without a designed system.

Rule of thumb: If you cannot confidently create a clean, porous, mechanically bondable surface, treat it as “needs prep” or “unsuitable” until a proven method is selected.

6) Decision tree: tile-ready vs needs prep vs unsuitable

Use this decision tree to make a clear call before installation. The goal is to avoid “maybe it’ll be fine” decisions.

START  → Identify substrate and location (floor/wall, dry/wet area)  →  Check structure/support  →  Check soundness  →  Check flat/plumb  →  Check moisture/contamination  →  Decide

Step-by-step decision tree (yes/no)

1. Is the substrate allowed for the location?
   • If NO (e.g., unstable plaster in a wet area; water-damaged gypsum; rotten wood): UNSUITABLE → remove/replace or redesign assembly.
   • If YES: continue.
2. Is it properly supported and rigid?
   • If NO (bounce, flex, inadequate subfloor thickness, loose wallboard): NEEDS PREP → stiffen framing/subfloor, add layer/underlayment, refasten.
   • If YES: continue.
3. Is it sound and well-bonded to its base?
   • If NO (crumbling concrete, delamination, hollow existing tile, loose plaster): UNSUITABLE if widespread; NEEDS PREP if localized and repairable.
   • If YES: continue.
4. Is it flat (and walls reasonably plumb) within target tolerances for your tile size?
   • If NO: NEEDS PREP → grind high spots, fill low spots with appropriate patch/leveling method, or re-plane/rebuild wall surfaces.
   • If YES: continue.
5. Is it clean and free of bond breakers (paint, sealers, oils, curing compounds), and acceptably dry?
   • If NO: NEEDS PREP → mechanical abrasion/removal, deep cleaning, moisture mitigation, or approved membrane system.
   • If YES: continue.
6. Final call
   • If all checks pass: TILE-READY.
   • If one or more checks require corrective work but are feasible: NEEDS PREP (document the prep steps before starting tile).
   • If multiple critical failures exist (structure + moisture + unsoundness) or the substrate is not approved for the environment: UNSUITABLE.

Example calls

• Concrete slab with light surface sealer, flat but water beads: NEEDS PREP → mechanically abrade to a clean, bondable surface; re-check flatness after grinding.
• Plywood floor that is flat but squeaks and feels bouncy: NEEDS PREP → refasten subfloor, address framing stiffness, add appropriate underlayment.
• Existing tile wall with several hollow-sounding areas and visible cracks: Often UNSUITABLE unless all loose areas can be removed and the remaining surface proven stable and flat.
• Drywall backsplash area, unpainted, firmly fastened, flat: TILE-READY (in a dry area) after cleaning dust and verifying flatness for the tile size.