BBQ Basics: Chicken Confidence—Juicy Pieces and Safe Results

Why Chicken Is the Perfect “Process Protein”

Chicken is forgiving when you use a repeatable process: cook gently until the inside is done, then use a short blast of higher heat to improve color and texture. The goal is simple: juicy meat, properly rendered skin (when present), and reliable doneness you can prove with a thermometer.

The most common beginner mistake is trying to “cook it all over direct heat” and chasing color. Color happens fast; doneness takes time. Instead, use a two-stage approach: indirect heat to cook through, then direct heat to finish.

Know Your Cuts: What Each Piece Needs

Doneness: Safety vs. Best Eating

Chicken is commonly served at 165°F (74°C) in the thickest part. For lean breast meat, many cooks pull slightly earlier and let carryover heat finish the job during a short rest. For thighs, drumsticks, and wings, higher internal temps usually improve tenderness and skin rendering.

Thermometer Confidence + Carryover Cooking

Where to Probe

• Breast: probe the thickest center, avoiding bone. If bone-in, probe near (not touching) the bone.
• Thigh: probe the thickest part, usually near where the thigh meets the body, avoiding bone.
• Drumstick: probe the thickest part of the meat, not right against the bone.
• Wings: probe the meatiest section (drumette), avoiding bone.

Carryover: Plan for the Rise

After you pull chicken off the grill, the internal temperature often rises 3–10°F (2–6°C) depending on piece size and how hot the exterior is. That’s why “pull temperature” matters: you’re aiming for the final temperature after resting, not the exact number the moment you remove it.

Repeatable Two-Zone Method: Indirect First, Direct Finish

This method works for every cut. Adjust only the pull temperature and the time you spend crisping over direct heat.

Continue in our app.

You can listen to the audiobook with the screen off, receive a free certificate for this course, and also have access to 5,000 other free online courses.

Or continue reading below...

Download the app

Step-by-Step

1. Prep for even cooking. Pat chicken dry. Trim excess skin flaps. For breasts, consider lightly pounding the thick end so the piece is more even in thickness.

2. Season. Apply your chosen seasoning (rub, marinade, or simple salt-forward blend). If using a sweet rub or sugary marinade, plan to keep it mostly on indirect heat and glaze late.

3. Start on indirect heat. Place chicken on the cooler side. Close the lid. This stage cooks the interior gently and reduces flare-ups.

   • Skin-on pieces: start skin-side up on indirect to render slowly without scorching.
   • Boneless breasts: keep them on indirect almost the entire time; they need only a brief direct finish (or none).

4. Flip once (optional) and rotate for evenness. About halfway through, flip if you want more even color, and rotate pieces so thicker pieces spend more time in the hotter indirect area.

5. Begin checking internal temperature early. Start probing when you think you’re within 10–15°F (6–8°C) of your pull target. Check multiple pieces; they rarely finish at the same time.

6. Move to direct heat to finish. When pieces are 5–15°F (3–8°C) below pull target, move them briefly over direct heat to deepen color and crisp skin.

   • Skin-on thighs/drumsticks/wings: direct heat is your crisping stage—short, attentive, and with frequent turning.
   • Breasts: direct heat should be very brief—just enough for light browning.

7. Pull at your target temperature. Remove pieces as they hit their pull temp (not all at once). Put them on a tray.

8. Rest. Rest uncovered or loosely tented. Tight foil traps steam and can soften skin.

Quick Reference: Pull Temperatures

• Breast: pull 155–160°F (68–71°C), rest to 160–165°F (71–74°C)
• Thighs/Drumsticks/Wings: pull 175–185°F (79–85°C) for best texture (or pull at 165°F if you prefer firmer texture)

Variations You Can Repeat

1) Simple Dry-Rub Thighs (Crisp Skin, Juicy Meat)

Best for: bone-in, skin-on thighs (also works for drumsticks).

1. Dry the skin well. Pat dry thoroughly. Moisture is the enemy of crisp skin.

2. Season with a low-sugar rub. Use a savory rub (salt-forward, pepper, garlic/onion, paprika). Avoid heavy sugar if you plan a direct finish.

3. Indirect cook. Place thighs skin-side up on indirect heat with lid closed until they reach about 165–170°F (74–77°C).

4. Direct crisp. Move to direct heat and turn frequently to crisp and color the skin. Pull at 175–185°F (79–85°C).

5. Rest 5–10 minutes. Keep skin exposed to air (no tight foil).

Practical cue: Skin should look slightly tightened and glossy, not pale and rubbery.

2) Marinated Chicken Skewers (Fast, Even Cooking)

Best for: boneless thigh or breast cut into even chunks.

• Cut size: aim for 1 to 1.5-inch (2.5–4 cm) cubes for even doneness.
• Skewer strategy: group similar sizes together; don’t mix breast and thigh on the same skewer.

1. Marinate. Use a marinade that’s not overly sugary if you’ll finish over direct heat. If it is sweet, plan a gentler finish and watch closely.

2. Thread evenly. Leave a little space between pieces so heat can circulate.

3. Indirect first (optional but helpful). Start skewers on indirect heat for a few minutes to cook through more gently.

4. Direct finish. Move to direct heat and turn often for even browning.

5. Pull temps: breast skewers at 155–160°F (68–71°C); thigh skewers at 175–185°F (79–85°C).

Practical cue: If the outside is browning too fast before the inside is close, move back to indirect and close the lid for a few minutes.

3) Wings with a Late Glaze (Crisp First, Sticky Later)

Best for: party wings (drumettes and flats).

1. Dry and season. Pat wings dry. Season with a savory rub (keep sugar low).

2. Indirect render. Cook on indirect heat with lid closed until wings are around 165–170°F (74–77°C).

3. Direct crisp. Move to direct heat, turning frequently, until skin is crisp and wings reach 175–185°F (79–85°C).

4. Glaze late. Brush glaze during the last 1–3 minutes over direct heat (or toss in glaze off-heat and return briefly). Turn constantly to avoid burning.

Practical cue: If glaze starts to darken quickly or smoke, pull the wings immediately and finish glazing off the grill.

Troubleshooting: Fix the Common Chicken Problems

Rubbery Skin

• Why it happens: skin didn’t render enough fat, or it steamed (too wet, too much foil, too low heat for the entire cook).
• Fix now: move skin-on pieces to direct heat and turn frequently to render and crisp; keep lid open briefly if you need to drive off surface moisture.
• Prevent next time: pat skin very dry; start indirect to cook through, then finish direct; avoid tight foil during rest.

Burnt Sugar Rubs or Glazes

• Why it happens: sugar scorches quickly over direct heat.
• Fix now: move back to indirect heat immediately; if glaze is burning, stop brushing and let the piece finish indirectly.
• Prevent next time: use low-sugar rubs for the cook and apply sweet glazes only at the end; keep the direct finish short and attentive.

Dry Breast Meat

• Why it happens: breast is lean and overshoots temperature quickly, especially if cooked too long over direct heat.
• Fix now: slice and serve with any resting juices; pair with a sauce at the table (don’t try to “cook it back” to juicy).
• Prevent next time: even out thickness; cook mostly indirect; pull at 155–160°F (68–71°C) and rest; avoid long direct finishing.

Uneven Cooking (Thick vs. Thin Pieces)

• Why it happens: mixed sizes and thicknesses finish at different times; some areas of the grill run hotter even on the indirect side.
• Fix now: move thinner pieces farther from heat; pull finished pieces early; keep thicker pieces cooking indirectly.
• Prevent next time: sort pieces by size; pound breasts to even thickness; place thicker pieces closer to the hotter indirect zone and rotate positions mid-cook.

Safe Resting and Serving Workflow (Without Soggy Skin)

1. Pull pieces to a clean tray as they hit pull temp. Don’t wait for “everything to be done” if some pieces are ready earlier.

2. Rest 5–10 minutes. This finishes carryover cooking and helps juices redistribute. Keep skin-on pieces uncovered or loosely tented.

3. Final temperature check (optional but confidence-building). Probe the thickest piece after a few minutes of rest to confirm you’re at your intended final temp.

4. Serve by cut. Slice breasts across the grain; serve thighs/drumsticks whole; toss wings in glaze off-heat if you want maximum crispness with sticky coating.

5. Hold briefly if needed. If you must hold chicken for a short time, keep it in a warm spot uncovered rather than sealed tightly (sealed traps steam and softens skin).