BBQ Basics: Burgers Done Right—From Patties to Perfect Sear

What “Done Right” Means for Burgers

A great burger balances three things: browning (deep sear and savory crust), juiciness (fat and moisture retained), and doneness (cooked to your target temperature). You get browning by putting a dry, well-shaped patty onto a properly hot grate; you get juiciness by choosing the right fat ratio and handling the meat gently; you get doneness by matching thickness to a cooking method and using a thermometer for thicker patties.

Meat Selection: Fat Ratio and Grind

Fat ratio guidelines

• 80/20 (20% fat): the classic choice for juicy burgers with strong browning. Great for most grills.
• 85/15: slightly leaner; still good, but easier to dry out if overcooked.
• 90/10: tends to cook up tight and dry; better saved for smash-style thin patties where cooking is very fast, or mix with fattier beef.

What to buy

• Freshly ground chuck is a reliable baseline: beefy flavor, good fat content.
• Brisket blends add richness; short rib blends add deep beef flavor (often pricier and fattier).
• If possible, ask for a coarse grind for a looser, steakier texture; fine grind can feel denser.

Rule of thumb: if you want a thick, juicy burger, start with 80/20 and don’t overwork it.

Gentle Handling: Keep It Loose

Over-mixing ground beef makes burgers springy and dense. Handle the meat like you’re shaping it, not kneading it.

• Keep meat cold until shaping so fat stays solid and doesn’t smear.
• Don’t mix in salt early (save seasoning for the outside) unless you specifically want a sausage-like texture.
• Form patties quickly, then return them to the fridge while the grill preheats.

Patty Shaping: Thickness, Edges, and the Dimple

Choose a patty style

• Thin patties (smash or thin-formed): 2.5–3.5 oz each, about 1/4–3/8 in thick. Best for fast direct cooking and maximum crust.
• Thick patties: 5–8 oz each, about 3/4–1 in thick. Best with a two-zone approach so the outside doesn’t burn before the center is done.

How to shape (step-by-step)

1. Portion the meat with a scale if you can (consistent cooking).
2. Form a puck by gently tucking edges under; avoid compressing hard.
3. Make edges slightly thicker than the center so they don’t overcook.
4. Thumb dimple: press a shallow dimple (about 1–2 in wide) in the center of each patty. This helps reduce “doming” as it cooks.
5. Square-ish is fine: patties shrink; starting slightly wider than the bun is smart.

Prevent crumbling

Crumbling usually comes from patties that are too loosely formed, too lean, or flipped too early. Use 80/20, form cohesive edges, and wait until a crust forms before the first flip.

Seasoning Timing: When to Salt

For classic burgers, season the outside only right before cooking. Salt draws moisture to the surface; if you salt too early and let it sit, the exterior can get wet and browning suffers, and the interior can tighten.

Continue in our app.

You can listen to the audiobook with the screen off, receive a free certificate for this course, and also have access to 5,000 other free online courses.

Or continue reading below...

Download the app

• Best practice: salt and pepper (or your favorite simple burger blend) immediately before the patty hits the grill.
• How much: a generous, even sprinkle from 8–10 inches above for uniform coverage.

Cooking Approaches

Approach A: Direct grilling for thin patties

Thin patties cook quickly and are hard to undercook if you stay attentive. The goal is fast browning without drying out.

Step-by-step

1. Preheat and clean the grate; then lightly oil the grate (not the patty) to reduce sticking.
2. Season patties right before cooking.
3. Place patties on the hottest area and don’t move them for the first 60–90 seconds to build crust.
4. Flip once you can lift cleanly with a spatula. Cook the second side until done.
5. Add cheese near the end (details below).

Timing note: thin patties are more about visual cues (browned edges, juices on top) and quick thermometer checks if you want precision.

Approach B: Two-zone method for thicker burgers

Thicker burgers benefit from a sear on the hot side and a gentler finish on the cooler side. This reduces the common problem of a burnt exterior with an undercooked center.

Step-by-step

1. Sear first: place patties on the hot side to brown both sides (build crust).
2. Move to cooler side: once you have good color, shift burgers to the cooler zone to finish to temperature without scorching.
3. Cover if available: closing the lid helps the interior cook evenly and helps cheese melt.
4. Thermometer check: start checking early; thick burgers can climb quickly near the end.

Doneness and Thermometer Guidance

For thicker burgers, a thermometer is the most reliable way to hit your target without guessing. Insert the probe from the side into the center of the patty for the most accurate reading.

Carryover cooking: thick burgers can rise a few degrees after coming off the grill. Pull slightly early if you’re targeting a precise doneness.

Cheese Melting: Fast, Even, and Not Greasy

When to add cheese

Add cheese when the burger is almost at your target temperature so it melts without overcooking the meat.

Techniques

• Lid-down melt: place cheese on the patty and close the lid for 30–60 seconds.
• Steam dome: cover the patty with a heat-safe metal bowl or dome for a quick melt (especially useful on open grills).
• Two-zone melt: move to the cooler side, add cheese, close lid; this prevents flare-ups from scorching the cheese.

Cheese choices: American melts smoothly; cheddar is flavorful but can split if overheated; pepper jack melts well and adds bite.

Bun Toasting: Texture and Heat Management

Toasting adds crunch, prevents sogginess, and warms the bun so the burger stays hot longer.

Step-by-step

1. Split buns and lightly butter or oil the cut sides.
2. Toast cut-side down over medium heat until golden.
3. Move off heat once toasted; buns can go from perfect to burnt fast.

Tip: if your grill runs hot, toast buns on the cooler zone while burgers finish.

Avoiding Common Burger Problems

Sticking to the grate

• Clean, hot grate: sticking is worse on a dirty grate.
• Oil the grate: fold a paper towel, dip in oil, and wipe the grate with tongs.
• Don’t rush the first flip: if it’s sticking, it usually needs more time to form a crust.

Crumbling or breaking when flipping

• Use enough fat: very lean meat breaks and dries.
• Form cohesive edges: cracks on the sides become break points.
• Flip with confidence: use a wide spatula; get fully under the patty.
• Wait for crust: early flips can tear the surface before it sets.

Flare-ups from dripping fat

• Expect some flare: burgers are fatty; manage it by moving patties briefly to a cooler area when flames spike.
• Keep lid strategy ready: closing the lid can reduce oxygen and calm flames on some grills; on others it can intensify heat—use what you’ve observed on your setup.
• Avoid excess oil: don’t oil the patties heavily; it increases dripping and flare-ups.

Pressing patties (why it dries them)

Pressing forces rendered fat and juices out of the meat—exactly what you’re trying to keep. The sizzle looks dramatic, but the result is a drier burger. The only time “pressing” makes sense is during a deliberate smash burger at the very start to maximize crust; once the patty is formed and cooking, don’t press.

Over-flipping: myth vs practical flipping

The idea that you must flip only once is overstated. What matters is not tearing the crust and not losing heat by fussing. For thin patties, 1–2 flips is typical. For thick burgers, you can flip a few times during the finishing phase to cook evenly—just avoid flipping so early that the patty sticks or breaks.

Simple Build Order (Assembly That Holds Together)

Build order is about stability, temperature, and preventing a soggy bun.

1. Bottom bun (toasted)
2. Condiment “barrier” (mayo or mayo-based sauce spreads well and helps resist soaking)
3. Lettuce (optional, also acts as a moisture barrier)
4. Burger patty (with melted cheese if using)
5. Onion/tomato/pickles (choose 1–2 so the burger stays balanced)
6. Top bun (toasted), with a light condiment if desired

Basic Condiment Strategy: Complement Smoke and Char

Char and smoke pair best with condiments that add creaminess, acidity, and a touch of sweetness—without burying beef flavor.

• Base: mayo (or a thin mayo + mustard mix) for richness and cling.
• Acid: pickles or a small swipe of yellow mustard to brighten the bite.
• Optional sweet/heat: a small amount of ketchup or a simple burger sauce; keep it light so the crust still tastes like crust.

Practical combo: mayo on the bottom bun, a few pickle slices, and a light mustard hit on the top bun—simple, classic, and it lets smoke and sear stay front and center.