Choosing Products and Reading Labels: Strength, pH Cues, and Formulation Clues

What You Can Learn From a Label (Without Being a Chemist)

When you shop for exfoliants, you’re not just choosing an “acid.” You’re choosing a formula: how strong it is, how it’s delivered (leave-on vs rinse-off), and how likely it is to irritate your skin. Labels and ingredient lists can’t tell you everything, but they can help you avoid common beginner mistakes—like buying a high-strength, fast-acting leave-on product with lots of fragrance and no clear directions.

The three label clues that matter most

• Strength cues: percentage (if disclosed) and product type (leave-on tends to act “stronger” than rinse-off).
• Acid identity: the specific exfoliant name in the ingredient list (not just “exfoliating complex”).
• Formulation cues: pH hints, alcohol/fragrance, buffering, and whether it’s a blend of multiple exfoliants.

Interpreting Percentages: What They Do (and Don’t) Tell You

Percentages are helpful, but they’re not the whole story. A lower percentage in a well-designed leave-on formula can feel more intense than a higher percentage in a buffered or rinse-off product.

How to use the percentage on the front label

• If a percentage is listed, treat it as a “potential intensity” flag. Higher numbers usually mean more exfoliating potential, but the formula can soften or amplify the feel.
• If no percentage is listed, use other cues: product type (leave-on vs rinse-off), where the acid appears in the ingredient list, and whether it’s a multi-acid blend.
• Be cautious with “peel,” “resurfacing,” “intensive,” or “clinical” language when the product is leave-on—these often signal a stronger experience even if the percentage isn’t obvious.

Where percentages can mislead beginners

• Different acids behave differently at the same percentage. “10%” doesn’t feel identical across all exfoliant types.
• Neutralized/buffered formulas can feel gentler. Two products can both say “10%,” but one may be designed to release activity more slowly.
• Layering changes the real-world strength. A moderate exfoliant used alongside other strong actives can behave like a “stronger routine” overall.

Finding the Acid on the Ingredient List: What to Look For

Ingredient lists (INCI lists) are your best tool for confirming what’s actually doing the exfoliating. You don’t need to memorize chemistry—just learn the common names and where they usually appear.

Common exfoliant names you may see

Step-by-step: how to scan an ingredient list quickly

1. Find the exfoliant name(s). Look specifically for “Glycolic Acid,” “Lactic Acid,” “Salicylic Acid,” or enzyme names like “Papain.”
2. Check if it’s a single active or a blend. Multiple exfoliants listed together (e.g., glycolic + lactic + salicylic) usually means a more complex, potentially stronger product.
3. Notice placement. Ingredients are listed from highest to lowest concentration (until the 1% line; below that, order can vary). If an acid is very far down the list, it may be present at a low level or used for pH adjustment rather than exfoliation.
4. Look for potential irritants near the top. High alcohol, heavy fragrance, or many essential oils can make a product feel harsher.

Marketing terms that don’t confirm exfoliation

• “Exfoliating complex” (could be acids, enzymes, or just plant extracts)
• “Fruit extract” (not the same as a meaningful enzyme or acid level)
• “AHA/BHA blend” without naming the acids (less transparent)

Prefer products that clearly name the exfoliant(s) and provide direct usage instructions.

pH Cues: What You Can Infer (and What You Can’t)

For many acid exfoliants, pH influences how “active” the acid is on skin. Most brands do not print pH on the label, but you can still use practical cues.

Continue in our app.

• Listen to the audio with the screen off.
• Earn a certificate upon completion.
• Over 5000 courses for you to explore!

Or continue reading below...

Download the app

Practical pH cues you may see

• Explicit pH range on packaging or product page: This is a transparency green flag. It doesn’t automatically mean “better,” but it helps you compare products.
• “pH-balanced” language: This is vague. It may refer to comfort rather than exfoliating performance.
• Very high stinging + watery alcohol base: Not a reliable pH indicator, but it can signal a formula that feels aggressive (stinging can come from alcohol/fragrance too).

What not to do

• Don’t try to “fix” a product’s pH by mixing it with other products in your hand. Mixing can change performance unpredictably and increase irritation risk.
• Don’t assume stronger is better. A product can be effective without feeling intense.

Why Formulation Matters More Than Beginners Expect

Two products with the same acid and percentage can behave very differently based on the vehicle (the base), supporting ingredients, and how long the product stays on your skin.

Leave-on vs rinse-off: the biggest real-world difference

• Leave-on (toners, serums, pads): Stays on skin, so it has more time to work. Beginners should be extra cautious with strength and frequency.
• Rinse-off (cleansers, wash-off masks): Short contact time can reduce intensity. This can be a gentler entry point for some people, but it can also be less predictable if you leave it on longer than directed.

Alcohol content: how to spot it and why it matters

High levels of certain alcohols can increase dryness and stinging, especially in leave-on exfoliants.

• Look for: Alcohol Denat., SD Alcohol, Ethanol near the top of the ingredient list.
• What it can mean: Faster-drying feel, potentially more irritation, and a “strong” sensory experience that’s not the same as better exfoliation.
• Note: Fatty alcohols like Cetearyl Alcohol or Cetyl Alcohol are different (they’re typically emollient and not the same concern).

Added fragrance and essential oils: common beginner tripwires

Fragrance can make an exfoliant harder to tolerate, especially if you’re new or easily sensitized.

• Look for: Fragrance (Parfum), Limonene, Linalool, Citral, Geraniol, and essential oils (e.g., lavender, citrus oils).
• Buying tip: If you’re unsure of your tolerance, choose fragrance-free for your first leave-on exfoliant.

Buffering and “gentle delivery” clues

Some formulas are designed to reduce the “hit” of an acid while still providing benefits.

• Buffering clues: language like “buffered,” “time-release,” or “encapsulated” (when explained clearly by the brand).
• Supportive base clues: humectants and soothing ingredients (for example, glycerin, panthenol, allantoin) can improve comfort. This doesn’t guarantee zero irritation, but it’s often a good sign for beginners.

Combination acid blends: effective but easier to overdo

Products that combine multiple exfoliants (e.g., AHA + BHA, or multiple AHAs) can be convenient, but they raise the chance of doing “too much” early on.

• Beginner approach: start with a single-active exfoliant so you can tell what your skin tolerates.
• When blends make sense: after you’ve used one exfoliant consistently without issues and you want a more targeted upgrade—while keeping the rest of your routine simple.

Practical Buying Guidelines for Beginners

1) Start with a single-active product

• Choose one primary exfoliant (one AHA, or salicylic acid, or an enzyme product) rather than a multi-acid cocktail.
• Pick a format you’ll use consistently (serum, toner, cleanser, mask) and follow the brand’s directions exactly at first.

2) Avoid stacking multiple strong exfoliants in the same routine initially

In the early weeks, keep your exfoliation “signal” clean so you can judge tolerance.

• Avoid pairing at first: leave-on acid + exfoliating scrub, leave-on acid + strong peel pads, or multiple acid products on the same day.
• Watch for hidden exfoliation: some acne treatments, “brightening” toners, and resurfacing masks may already contain acids.

3) Prioritize products with clear, specific usage instructions

Clear directions reduce the chance of accidental overuse.

• Good signs: “Use X times per week,” “Apply to dry skin,” “Avoid eye area,” “Do not combine with other exfoliants,” and guidance on rinse time if applicable.
• Less helpful signs: “Use as needed,” “Use daily for best results” with no mention of tolerance building, or no warnings about sensitive areas.

4) Choose packaging that supports stability and hygiene

• Best for many leave-ons: pump bottles or squeeze tubes (less air and finger contact).
• Be cautious with: open jars (more contamination risk) and pre-soaked pads if you’re sensitive or if you won’t use them quickly.

Mini Checklist: Choosing Your First Exfoliant (Skin Type + Tolerance)

Use this as a quick shopping filter. Choose the option that matches your skin and your preference for leave-on vs rinse-off.

Safe Storage and Usage Hygiene (Often Overlooked)

Clean application habits

• Wash hands before applying leave-on exfoliants. This reduces introducing bacteria into the product and onto freshly exfoliated skin.
• If you use cotton pads: use a fresh pad each time. Don’t “double dip” a used pad back onto a bottle opening or cap.
• Avoid sharing exfoliant products (especially pads and jars).

Prevent contamination and degradation

• Close caps tightly and store away from heat and direct sunlight (a cool, dry cabinet is usually ideal).
• Don’t dilute products with water in the bottle to “make them gentler.” This can destabilize preservatives and increase contamination risk.
• Watch for changes: unusual odor, color shift, separation that doesn’t remix, or new stinging that wasn’t there before can signal the product is no longer in good condition.

Follow expiration and PAO (Period After Opening)

Many products show either an expiration date or a PAO symbol (an open jar icon like 6M, 12M, 24M).

• Expiration date: use by that date regardless of when you opened it.
• PAO: once opened, aim to finish within that number of months.
• Tip: write the open date on the bottle with a small sticker so you don’t have to guess later.