Choosing Fulfillment: FBM vs FBA and When Each Makes Sense

FBM vs FBA: What You’re Actually Choosing

On Amazon, “fulfillment” is the operational system that gets an order from “paid” to “delivered,” including shipping, customer messages, and returns. Your two main options are:

• FBM (Fulfilled by Merchant): you store inventory, pick/pack, buy shipping labels, ship orders, handle most customer service, and process returns.
• FBA (Fulfilled by Amazon): you send inventory to Amazon’s fulfillment centers; Amazon stores it, ships orders, handles most customer service, and manages most returns.

Neither is “better” in all cases. The right choice depends on your product’s size/weight, margin, sales velocity, operational capacity, and how sensitive customers are to delivery speed.

A Decision Framework: Compare FBM and FBA Across 7 Factors

1) Cost (Per-Unit Fulfillment + Hidden Operational Costs)

FBA typically includes fulfillment fees (pick/pack/ship), storage fees, and sometimes additional fees (e.g., long-term storage, removal/disposal). FBM costs include shipping postage, packaging materials, labor/time, and any software or warehouse costs.

• FBA tends to win when your item is small/light, sells consistently, and you value predictable per-unit costs.
• FBM tends to win when your item is oversized/heavy, slow-moving, or you can ship cheaply (negotiated rates, regional advantage, or manufacturer drop-ship).

Practical comparison tip: estimate a “true FBM cost” by adding labor and error allowance, not just postage.

2) Speed (Delivery Promise and Customer Expectations)

Fast delivery increases conversion for many categories. FBA often provides faster, more consistent delivery because inventory is already positioned within Amazon’s network. FBM can be fast too, but only if you ship same-day/next-day reliably and use appropriate shipping services.

Continue in our app.

You can listen to the audiobook with the screen off, receive a free certificate for this course, and also have access to 5,000 other free online courses.

Or continue reading below...

Download the app

• Choose FBA if speed is a major buying factor (common for commodity items, replenishment products, and competitive listings).
• Choose FBM if you can match speed reliably (e.g., you’re near your customer base, you ship daily, and you can maintain strong on-time delivery).

3) Workload (Daily Operations and Scalability)

FBM workload scales with orders: more sales means more picking, packing, and shipping. FBA shifts most of that workload to Amazon, so you focus more on inventory planning and replenishment.

• FBA makes sense when you want to scale without building a shipping operation.
• FBM makes sense when order volume is low/irregular or you already have fulfillment capability.

4) Customer Service (Messages, Delivery Issues, and Expectations)

With FBA, Amazon handles most delivery-related customer service. With FBM, you handle customer messages and delivery issues directly (missing packages, address problems, shipping delays).

• FBA reduces the number of operational customer service tickets you must resolve.
• FBM requires consistent monitoring and fast response times, especially during weekends/holidays.

5) Returns (Cost, Complexity, and Restock Decisions)

Returns are part of Amazon. The difference is who processes them and how much control you have.

• FBA: Amazon typically authorizes and processes returns; you may receive returned inventory back into sellable/unsellable status depending on condition.
• FBM: you manage return address, inspection, refunds, and restocking decisions.

Rule of thumb: if your product has a high return rate or requires inspection (fragile, high-value, condition-sensitive), plan your workflow carefully regardless of method.

6) Storage Limits and Inventory Risk (Space, Aged Inventory, and Sell-Through)

FBA storage is not unlimited. You can face storage limits and higher fees for aged inventory. FBM storage is “your problem,” but you control it and can hold slow-moving items without Amazon storage penalties (though you still pay your own carrying costs).

• FBA makes sense when you have healthy sell-through and can replenish in smaller, frequent shipments.
• FBM makes sense when demand is uncertain, seasonal, or slow-moving and you want to avoid aged inventory fees.

7) Cash Flow (When Money Leaves vs When It Comes Back)

Fulfillment choice changes when cash is tied up:

• FBA: you pay inbound shipping and commit inventory to Amazon; storage fees accrue over time; stranded/aged inventory can lock up cash.
• FBM: you may keep inventory at home/warehouse and ship as orders come in; you pay shipping per order (ongoing variable cost) and can pause sales without paying Amazon storage.

Cash-flow lens: if you’re tight on cash, avoid sending large quantities to FBA until you have evidence of steady sales velocity.

Prime Eligibility: What It Is and Why It Changes Results

How Prime Eligibility Works (Practical View)

Prime eligibility means Prime customers see a Prime badge and typically get faster shipping promises. In practice:

• FBA offers are usually Prime-eligible because Amazon controls fulfillment.
• FBM offers are usually not Prime-eligible unless you qualify for a seller-fulfilled Prime program (availability and requirements vary) or use specific Amazon-supported fulfillment options that enable Prime-like delivery promises.

Prime eligibility can increase conversion because many shoppers filter for Prime or strongly prefer it.

Fulfillment Choice, Buy Box, and Conversion

Even when you already understand the Buy Box concept, it helps to know how fulfillment affects your competitiveness:

• Conversion rate: faster, more reliable delivery promises (often FBA/Prime) can lift conversion, especially on competitive listings.
• Buy Box competitiveness: Amazon generally favors offers that deliver reliably with strong customer experience metrics. FBA often performs well here because shipping performance is standardized.
• FBM can still win if you consistently ship fast, keep cancellation/late shipment rates low, and price competitively—especially in niches where Prime is less critical or items are oversized.

Practical takeaway: if you’re competing against multiple Prime offers on the same listing, FBM may require a stronger price advantage or exceptional shipping speed to maintain similar conversion.

Step-by-Step: Choose FBM or FBA Using a Simple Scorecard

Use this quick process before you commit inventory:

Step 1: Gather your product inputs

• Item size/weight (packed dimensions)
• Expected monthly sales (conservative estimate)
• Margin per unit (after product cost)
• Fragility/return sensitivity
• Your available shipping time (daily cutoff, weekends)
• Storage space available (home/warehouse)

Step 2: Estimate “true FBM cost per order”

Include more than postage:

• Shipping label cost (average zone)
• Packaging (box, dunnage, tape, label)
• Labor/time (assign a realistic value per shipment)
• Error buffer (lost packages, reships, occasional refunds)

Example (simple): If postage is $6.50, packaging is $0.60, and you estimate $2.00 labor/time, your true FBM fulfillment cost is about $9.10 per order (before occasional exceptions).

Step 3: Estimate FBA costs and constraints

• FBA fulfillment fee estimate for size tier
• Monthly storage estimate (based on cubic feet and expected time in storage)
• Inbound shipping to Amazon (per unit)
• Risk of aged inventory fees if it doesn’t sell

Decision point: if FBA is only slightly more expensive but meaningfully improves delivery promise and reduces workload, it may be worth it.

Step 4: Score each factor (1–5) and pick the best fit

Pick the method with the higher total score, then sanity-check it against your operational reality (time, space, and risk tolerance).

Hybrid Strategies: Practical Ways Beginners Can Combine FBM and FBA

Strategy A: Start FBM to Validate Demand, Then Move to FBA

This approach reduces the risk of sending too much inventory to Amazon before you know it sells.

• When it makes sense: new product, uncertain velocity, limited cash, or you want to test packaging durability and return patterns.
• How to do it (steps):
  1. Launch as FBM with a conservative stock level you can store and ship.
  2. Track actual weekly sales and operational effort (minutes per order, shipping cost variance, customer messages).
  3. Once sales are consistent, calculate how many units you can safely send to FBA (often 2–6 weeks of expected sales, depending on replenishment speed).
  4. Send a small FBA shipment; keep some units for FBM as a backup while you learn the inbound process.

Key benefit: you avoid paying FBA storage on inventory that might not move.

Strategy B: Split Inventory (FBA for Prime Demand + FBM as Backup)

You can keep part of your inventory at Amazon for Prime conversion and keep part locally to reduce stockout risk.

• When it makes sense: you have moderate sales, occasional inbound delays, or you want redundancy during peak seasons.
• How to do it (steps):
  1. Send a core quantity to FBA to capture Prime demand.
  2. Keep reserve stock for FBM or for quick replenishment to FBA.
  3. If FBA goes out of stock or becomes constrained, you can continue selling via FBM (if your metrics and handling time allow).

Operational note: splitting inventory requires tighter tracking so you don’t oversell or misjudge reorder points.

Strategy C: Use FBA for Small/Fast Items, FBM for Oversized or Slow Movers

Not all SKUs should be fulfilled the same way.

• When it makes sense: you sell a mix of products with different size tiers and velocity.
• How to do it: assign FBA to items where Prime and low per-unit fulfillment costs matter most; keep bulky, fragile, or slow-moving items as FBM to avoid high fees and aged inventory risk.

Beginner Pitfalls (and How to Avoid Them)

Pitfall 1: Underestimating FBM Handling Time

Many beginners calculate FBM using only postage and forget the daily operational load.

• What goes wrong: late shipments, missed scans, weekend backlog, higher cancellation rates, and more customer messages.
• How to avoid it: time yourself packing 10 orders; multiply by your realistic daily volume; set a daily cutoff; pre-build packaging stations; keep supplies stocked.

Pitfall 2: Assuming FBM Can Match Prime Without a System

Fast delivery is not just buying faster shipping—it’s consistent same-day/next-day handling.

• What goes wrong: you pay for expedited shipping but still ship late because you can’t process orders quickly.
• How to avoid it: commit to a handling time you can meet every day, including busy periods; schedule pickups; avoid selling items you can’t pack quickly.

Pitfall 3: Ignoring FBA Storage Limits and Aged Inventory Fees

FBA is not “set and forget.” Inventory that sits too long can become expensive and can restrict your ability to send more stock.

• What goes wrong: cash gets trapped in slow-moving units; storage fees accumulate; you hesitate to lower price or run promotions because you’re trying to “wait it out.”
• How to avoid it: send smaller initial quantities; replenish based on sell-through; review inventory age regularly; plan removal or liquidation decisions early.

Pitfall 4: Sending Too Much to FBA Before You Know the True Demand

Beginners often overestimate sales velocity.

• What goes wrong: you pay storage while learning; you may need removals; you lose flexibility to pivot.
• How to avoid it: treat your first FBA shipment as a test batch; aim for weeks of coverage, not months, until the SKU proves itself.

Pitfall 5: Not Planning for Returns and Unsellable Inventory

Returns happen in both models, but the workflow differs.

• What goes wrong: you don’t budget for return shipping/processing (FBM) or you ignore unsellable returns and removal decisions (FBA).
• How to avoid it: set a per-unit “returns allowance” in your margin calculations; define what you do with returned units (resell, refurbish, dispose) before volume grows.

Pitfall 6: Choosing Fulfillment Without Considering Cash Flow Timing

Even profitable products can create cash crunches if inventory is tied up.

• What goes wrong: you can’t reorder winners because money is stuck in slow FBA stock.
• How to avoid it: keep reorder quantities conservative; prioritize high-velocity SKUs for FBA; keep optionality with FBM or smaller replenishments.