Account Health and Performance Metrics: Preventing Suspensions and Suppressed Listings

What “Account Health” Really Measures

Amazon evaluates your ability to deliver a reliable customer experience and follow marketplace rules. Your Account Health page aggregates performance metrics (how well you fulfill orders) and policy compliance (whether your listings and operations follow rules). Problems typically show up in three ways:

• Account-level risk: warnings, policy violations, or deactivation risk.
• Offer-level risk: a specific ASIN/offer removed or restricted.
• Listing-level visibility issues: a listing is suppressed (not searchable/buyable) due to missing/invalid data or content violations.

Your goal is to treat metrics as leading indicators (early warning signals) and build routines that prevent them from drifting.

Core Performance Metrics That Drive Account Health

1) Order Defect Rate (ODR)

Concept: ODR is a composite metric that reflects customer-facing defects. It commonly includes negative feedback, A-to-z Guarantee claims, and chargebacks. Even a small number of defects can matter if your order volume is low.

Why it spikes:

• Product not as described (wrong variation, inaccurate attributes).
• Damaged/defective units.
• Late delivery leading to claims.
• Poor customer support or unresolved issues.

Step-by-step: reduce ODR

Continue in our app.

You can listen to the audiobook with the screen off, receive a free certificate for this course, and also have access to 5,000 other free online courses.

Or continue reading below...

Download the app

1. Identify the defect source (feedback vs claim vs chargeback) and list the affected order IDs.
2. Confirm root cause by checking: listing accuracy, packing method, carrier scan history, and customer messages.
3. Fix the cause: update listing facts, improve packaging, tighten pick/pack checks, or adjust handling time.
4. Recover where appropriate: if feedback is clearly about shipping handled by a carrier or contains prohibited content, request removal through the proper channel; otherwise address the customer issue operationally.

2) Cancellation Rate (Pre-fulfillment Cancel Rate)

Concept: Measures how often you cancel orders before shipping. Amazon expects you to maintain accurate inventory and realistic handling times.

Common causes:

• Overselling due to inventory sync delays.
• Supplier stockouts (for wholesale/retail arbitrage models).
• Handling time too aggressive for your workflow.
• Address issues you cancel instead of resolving.

Step-by-step: reduce cancellations

1. Audit cancellation reasons for the last 30–60 days and categorize (out of stock, cannot ship, buyer request, address issue).
2. Fix inventory accuracy: set buffer quantities (e.g., keep 2–5 units “reserved” so they never list), and shorten sync intervals if using software.
3. Adjust handling time to what you can consistently meet (better to be slightly slower than to cancel/ship late).
4. Create an “address resolution” script: message the buyer promptly for clarification instead of canceling when possible.

3) Late Shipment Rate (LSR)

Concept: Percentage of orders confirmed shipped after the expected ship date. This is about ship confirmation timing, not just delivery.

Common causes:

• Printing labels late or confirming shipment after pickup.
• Weekend/holiday cutoffs not reflected in handling time.
• Operational bottlenecks (batching too late in the day).

Step-by-step: reduce late shipments

1. Set a daily cutoff (e.g., orders by 1pm ship same day; after 1pm ship next business day).
2. Move ship confirmation earlier: confirm shipment when the carrier has the package (or at least when it is handed off), not at end of day.
3. Use a dispatch checklist: label printed → packed → weight check → scan/manifest → handoff.
4. Review handling time quarterly and adjust for peak seasons.

4) Valid Tracking Rate (VTR)

Concept: Measures whether you provide valid tracking information that can be verified by the carrier. It’s not enough to paste a number—Amazon checks carrier format and scan events.

Common causes:

• Using untracked shipping methods for categories where tracking is expected.
• Entering tracking numbers incorrectly or using the wrong carrier selection.
• Buying labels off-platform that don’t generate reliable scans.

Step-by-step: improve VTR

1. Standardize carriers you use most often and train on correct carrier selection in Seller Central.
2. Buy trackable services for order types/categories where tracking is required or strongly expected.
3. Validate before confirming: spot-check that the tracking number format matches the carrier and that the first scan typically appears within 24–48 hours.
4. Investigate “no scan” lanes: if a specific drop-off location regularly misses acceptance scans, switch drop-off points or schedule pickups.

5) Returns Dissatisfaction (Return-Related Customer Experience)

Concept: Amazon monitors signals that customers are unhappy with returns (e.g., complaints about refunds, restocking disputes, slow processing, or confusing return experiences). Even if you follow the rules, inconsistent handling can trigger complaints and performance flags.

Common causes:

• Slow refunds after receipt.
• Disputes without clear evidence.
• Condition issues (items arriving used/damaged) leading to higher return rates and complaints.

Step-by-step: reduce returns dissatisfaction

1. Set an internal SLA (e.g., inspect and refund within 48 hours of return delivery).
2. Use an inspection rubric: unopened/new, opened/resellable, damaged, missing parts; document with photos.
3. Track top return reasons by ASIN and fix upstream causes (packaging, instructions, variation selection clarity).
4. Keep customer messages factual and fast—delays create dissatisfaction even when you are “right.”

Policy Compliance Areas That Commonly Trigger Risk

Performance metrics are only half the picture. Policy issues can suppress listings, remove offers, or escalate to account actions. Focus on these practical compliance areas:

• Product authenticity and condition accuracy: ensure your offer condition matches the item; keep purchase documentation organized.
• Listing content compliance: avoid prohibited claims, restricted terms, or content that implies medical/regulated outcomes without proper authorization.
• Image compliance: meet main-image rules and avoid overlays, watermarks, and misleading depictions.
• Variation integrity: don’t combine unrelated products under one parent; mismatched variations can cause complaints and enforcement.
• Restricted products/keywords: certain terms can trigger review even if the product itself seems harmless.

Suppressed Listings: A Diagnostic Flow and Safe Fixes

A suppressed listing usually means the ASIN exists but is not eligible to display because required data is missing/invalid or content violates rules. Treat suppression like a controlled troubleshooting process: identify the suppression reason, fix the minimum necessary fields, and document changes.

Step 1: Confirm the Suppression Type

1. Check Manage All Inventory for “Suppressed” status and any “Fix listing” prompts.
2. Open the listing quality/details page (where available) to see missing attributes or policy flags.
3. Check for category-specific requirements (some categories require extra attributes like material, battery info, or compliance fields).

Step 2: Use This Diagnostic Flow

START → Listing is suppressed / not searchable / not buyable?  YES → Identify reason shown in Seller Central (if any) → Then check in this order:  1) Missing/invalid required attributes?     - Examples: brand, item type, size, color, GTIN, material, battery fields, compliance attributes     → Fix via Edit Listing or flat file; wait for processing; re-check.  2) Restricted keywords or sensitive terms detected?     - Examples: medical/drug claims, weapons terms, adult terms, pesticide/chemical claims     → Remove/replace terms in title/bullets/description/backend; ensure claims are factual and allowed.  3) Image violations?     - Examples: non-white background on main image, text/graphics overlays, watermarks, collage, props that mislead, adult imagery     → Replace images with compliant versions; confirm main image meets requirements.  4) Category/brand/GTIN conflicts?     - Examples: wrong category, brand mismatch, GTIN doesn't match product identity     → Correct category/attributes; if you cannot, stop editing and escalate with evidence.  5) Still suppressed after 24–48 hours?     → Open a case with Seller Support; provide ASIN, screenshots, and exact fields changed.

Common Suppression Causes and Safe Corrections

How to Correct Suppressed Listings Without Creating New Problems

• Change one variable at a time: make a small set of edits, then wait for processing before additional changes.
• Keep an edit log: date/time, fields changed, old value → new value, reason, screenshot links.
• Use accurate, verifiable facts: if you can’t prove it on packaging or documentation, don’t claim it.
• Avoid “keyword surgery” that changes meaning: removing restricted terms is good; replacing them with misleading synonyms is not.

Incident Response Playbook: From First Alert to Stabilization

When you get a performance notification, policy warning, listing removal, or account risk alert, speed matters—but so does precision. Use a structured playbook so you don’t make the situation worse with rushed edits.

Phase 1: Triage (First 30–60 Minutes)

1. Capture the current state: screenshots of the notification, affected ASINs, and any error messages.
2. Define the scope: account-wide vs specific ASIN vs specific orders.
3. Stop the bleeding: if a listing is clearly problematic, consider setting quantity to zero or closing the listing temporarily while you investigate (especially for policy-related issues).
4. Assign an owner: one person responsible for updates and documentation to avoid conflicting actions.

Phase 2: Evidence Collection and Root Cause Analysis

Create an incident folder and collect:

• Order data: order IDs, ship dates, carrier, tracking, messages.
• Listing snapshots: title, bullets, images, attributes at time of incident.
• Operational proof: packing photos (if you have them), carrier receipts, supplier invoices (when relevant), inspection notes.
• Timeline: when the issue started, when you noticed, what changed recently (price edits, content edits, supplier change, warehouse change).

Root cause method (simple and effective):

• What happened? (observable fact)
• Why did it happen? (process failure)
• What control failed? (missing check, unclear SOP, tool misconfiguration)
• What will prevent recurrence? (specific control you will implement)

Phase 3: Corrective Actions (Fix Now)

Choose actions that directly address the root cause:

• Metrics issue: adjust handling time, change carrier method, improve inventory buffers, retrain pack process, add daily cutoff.
• Suppressed listing: fix required attributes, remove restricted terms, replace images, correct variation structure.
• Policy issue: remove/disable the problematic content or offer, correct claims, and ensure documentation is organized.

Document each action with date/time and the exact change made.

Phase 4: Communication and Appeals (When Needed)

Not every issue requires an appeal. Use an appeal when Amazon has taken an enforcement action (e.g., listing removed for policy, account deactivated) and requests a Plan of Action (POA) or when you need reinstatement.

Professional Appeal Structure (POA Template)

Keep it concise, factual, and specific. Avoid emotional language or blaming Amazon, customers, or carriers.

Subject: Plan of Action – [Account/ASIN] – [Issue Type]  1) Root Cause (what caused the issue) - In 1–3 bullets, explain the true operational/content cause. - Reference the specific ASIN(s) or process step involved.  2) Corrective Actions Taken (what you already did) - Bullet list with dates: removed/edited content, replaced images, adjusted handling time, refunded affected orders, etc. - Include objective proof where appropriate (case IDs, screenshots, tracking evidence).  3) Preventive Measures (how you will prevent recurrence) - New SOPs, checklists, audits, training, system controls (inventory buffers, daily shipment audits, listing compliance checklist). - Include frequency (daily/weekly/monthly) and ownership (role responsible).

Appeal Writing Checklist

• Specificity: mention ASINs, order IDs, dates, and exact fields changed.
• Ownership: “We implemented…” not “Carrier caused…”
• Controls: add measurable routines (e.g., “daily VTR audit at 4pm”).
• Attachments: only relevant documents; label them clearly (Invoice_ASIN_Date.pdf, Tracking_Receipt_OrderID.pdf).

Preventive SOPs: Turn Metrics Into Daily/Weekly Routines

Preventive SOPs are simple, repeatable checks that keep you out of trouble. Below are practical SOPs you can implement immediately.

Daily SOP (15–30 Minutes)

• Shipment cutoff check: confirm today’s orders can ship within handling time; proactively message buyers if needed.
• Tracking quality spot-check: verify a sample of shipments have correct carrier + tracking format.
• Inventory buffer review: confirm top sellers have buffer quantities and no negative inventory.
• Account Health glance: look for new notifications, policy warnings, or sudden metric movement.

Weekly SOP (30–60 Minutes)

• ODR driver review: list any negative feedback/claims/chargebacks; identify patterns by ASIN.
• Cancellation reason audit: categorize cancellations and implement one fix per top category.
• Late shipment audit: review orders shipped near the deadline; adjust staffing/cutoffs if needed.
• Suppression sweep: filter inventory for suppressed/inactive listings and resolve using the diagnostic flow.

Monthly SOP (60–120 Minutes)

• Listing compliance audit: sample 10–20 ASINs; verify images, attributes, and claims remain compliant after any edits.
• Process stress test: simulate a high-volume day and confirm your workflow still meets handling time and tracking standards.
• Returns reason analysis: identify top return reasons and implement product/packaging/listing improvements.

Quick Reference: “If This, Then That”